Tag: tax

Taxing the super rich a bit more is a progressive policy

The piece below was written for the Guardian's Comment is Free website.

"At our best when at our boldest": the words of one T Blair to Labour's party conference in 2002. He was right, of course, and should he be speaking with Gordon prior to the leader's speech on Tuesday, I hope he will take the opportunity to remind him of what he said and why he said it. Labour is – despite the cynics (many in our own party) who argue otherwise – a centre-left party, not a centre-right one. Labour's centre-left credentials since 1997 have been impressive: the introduction of the minimum wage, the abolition of the assisted places scheme, more help for pensioners, the hereditary principle in the Lords, huge investment in the NHS, debt cancellation etc, etc. The problem is that many of these radical and socially progressive initiatives were carried out during the first term. Since 2001 Labour has been, on the whole, competent but not radical, managerial but not inspirational.

As Labour gathers in Manchester it is clear to all that things have to change if Gordon Brown is to have any chance of turning Labour's (and his own) fortunes around. Yet strangely I am more optimistic about Labour's future today than I have been for some time. Why? Bizarrely, the tumultuous events on the world's financial markets in the past few days offer Labour a unique opportunity to stage a fight back and to put some clear red water between themselves and the City-friendly Tories. According to a Institute for Fiscal Studies the highest-earning 0.1% of the UK population enjoy an average annual income of £780,043. This is around 31 times higher than the national average income of £24,000. Given the present context, and given Gordon's commitment to fairness and equity, surely a national debate (led by the PM himself) about whether the very wealthy should contribute a bit more through the tax system would be most welcome. The public has watched on in horror and disgust at the City traders who deliberately bid down bank shares, bet on the failure of key stock and companies and even – it is suggested – spread false rumours in order to line their own already very deep and very full pockets. The debate should not be dominated by where the cut-off should be placed for any new tax (should it kick in at £150,000, £250,000 etc). Rather, it should be a debate about the principle of such a tax.


Talking about such issues could well be fertile ground for Labour and make life distinctly uncomfortable for David Cameron and his front bench. Cameron's Conservatives are made up of the "right kind of people", his people – privately educated and from backgrounds of immense wealth and privilege. Under Cameron, the Tories still believe that the role of government is to concentrate wealth and power in the hands of those who embrace their political, economic, and social views. For these reasons, Cameron would be reluctant to get into a debate about the super-rich and what they should or should not contribute via the tax system.


Brown should be bold. He has little to lose either personally or politically but both he and the nation have, potentially, a good deal to gain.


Obama v McCain : It's Class, Stupid!


McCain now , all of a sudden, seems to be stealing Obama’s change-agent, pro working and middle class, clothes.

The US Tax Policy Institute’s 14 August comparative analysis (reported by Money & Markets) of the two candidates’ proposed tax burden (below) shows that 7-property-owner McCain clearly knows which side of his bread to further butter!

Cherchez le windfall

A Very Telling article written by the BBC's buisness correspondent, Robert Peston  

Ivan Lewis: Tax the rich not the middle classes

I'm liking Ivan Lewis, he seemed very angry about the Tories "Vermin" press release a few weeks ago. He called it gutter politcs and I'd say that was a 100% accurate view on things. In the Times today, he says "Tax the Rich not the Middle Classes", another sentiment I totally agree with.

The Myth of Rising Taxes under Labour

Many taxes for the poor have fallen

Car Tax - the new 10p Tax own-goal?

Is the new Car Tax proposals that we were told would affect only a minority of people, but which today's reports indicate will actually affect over 40% of families, another rerun of the 10 tax proposals that also wouldn't hurt many people?

My vision for the future

A Labourhome member writes

New Labour is dead in the water; its electoral credibility has been shattered and it's time we took a long hard look in the mirror, remember what we believe in, what we joined this great party for and look to the future. Gordon is the past, and he needs to go sooner rather than later if we are to remain a force in British politics. Here's my vision for the future, not for now, not necessarily for 2010 but for the long term health of the party.

£600 on Tax Allowance: 10p tax sorted

The Chancellor, in a statement to Parliament, has just revealed that the government plans to increase the personal Income Tax allowance by £600 pounds - and backdate this to the beginning of the financial year.

This is a brilliant and welcome resolution to the 10p tax fiasco and the government rightly deserves great praise for listening and for creating a wide-ranging solution. It makes people happy when they have more money in their pocket (without complicated bureaucracy) and we have a very effective message to give to voters on the door step when we are asked about what the party is doing for them.

Making work pay!

Ask your MP to sign Early Day Motion 1407, calling for the personal allowance for Income Tax and NIC to be increased to £10,000.

http://edmi.parliament.uk/EDMi/EDMDetails.aspx?EDMID=35657&SESSION=891

Why the 10% starting rate had to go

People need to look at the tax system in the round before criticising individual aspects of it. What those who decry the removal of the 10% starting rate conveniently forget is that - due to the tax credit system - it is the wealthy, not the poor, who will lose most from it.


10p or not 10p: Ask Gordon on live webcast tonight

Gordon Brown is conducting a live webcast at 7 pm tonight. Why not focus on the one issue increasingly dominiating the airwaves? Tell him what you think about the cost of the 10p income tax band cut on 5.3 million hard-working people, and ask him to fix it.
Details of how to send in your question either by eMail or text are set out below.
Peter Kenyon
chair, Save the Labour Party

PROGRESS: Join the debate over John Hutton's Progress speech

Last week, John Hutton gave the opening speech in Progress' Progressive Challenge series, in which he argued that 'rather than questioning whether high salaries are morally justified, we should celebrate the fact that people can be enormously successful in this country.'

This week, we will be publishing a number of response articles, exclusive to Progress Online. Today's contributions come from Ruth Lister, Professor of Social Policy at Loughborough Univeristy, and the Labour blogger Luke Akehurst.

'Hutton’s ‘progressive individualism’ thus represents a dead end for those committed to the eradication of child poverty. It also offers a picture of a society that I, for one, do not want to live in. Successive British Social Attitudes Surveys, which reveal that the public appear to be more affronted by the levels of incomes at the top than the bottom, suggest that I am not alone.' - Ruth Lister >

'If anything, aspirational views are stronger amongst Labour's core working class supporters - who want a better material future for themselves and their children - than amongst more middle class voters who are already comfortably off and often want to pull up the drawbridge of opportunity behind them.' - Luke Akehurst >

Tomorrow: Derek Draper and Alex Kemp.


Well said Frank Field

According to Frank Field "super rich" should pay a minimum of 10% more tax on any earnings over £150,000 (or give the same amount to a charity of their choice). Field suggest that such a move could raise £3.6bn a year.


What do you think? Personally I think it has real merit.


Ashcroft still not paying tax in the UK?

If Lord Ashcroft is putting hundreds of thousands of pounds into Tory campaigns, why isn't he putting money into the UK exchequer?

It seems despite promises by William Hague that the Conservative's biggest donor would move back to the UK and pay income tax here, Ashcroft is still avoiding tax whilst pumping money into marginal seats.

http://politics.guardian.co.uk/conservatives/story/0,,2208695,00.html

Andy Burnham: "Taxes should recognise marriage"



Can't say I'm a fan of Chief Secretary to the Treasury Andy Burnham anyway, but I think his comments here have plummeted him to a new low.


Brown to close private equity tax loophole



The government will close a tax loophole that allows fat-cat bosses to pay less tax than their office cleaners, Gordon Brown said today.

The prime minister vowed to take action on private equity chiefs in the pre-budget report later this year.


During a wide-ranging question-and-answer session with Mariella Frostrup, the TV and radio presenter, at the Labour party conference in Bournemouth, Mr Brown said: "Whenever there is a loophole that shouldn't exist we take action. Since 1997 we have closed a massive number.

"Sometimes it is very difficult to do so because you have lawyers and accountants who are always trying to find these loopholes.


"But on this issue of private equity I can assure you that we will do so."


Carbon tax, carbon benefit

The fairest "green tax" would be to significantly increase taxes on all fuel (including red diessel and aircraft fuel) and increase VAT on domestic power to 17.5% to whatever figure is needed to reflect the CO2 that they produce and damage to the environment etc (assuming that anybody knows what the true cost of this is - I certainly don't).

The government should then distribute the total receipts per capita to everybody in the UK as a Universal Benefit.


How will Brown react?

An interesting story by the Independent political editor Andrew Grice, about how Gordon Brown's 'new collegiate style' will be tested next week.

Has Hewitt been at the bottle?

More tax on alcohol would be misguided.

Brown 1 Byers 0

Is Brown finally showing what he can do when he puts his mind to it.

Next 20 >>