Tag: abortion

Abortion debate: keep party politics out of it

When shadow Health Secretary, Dr Liam Fox appeared to suggest that the Tories should become the anti-abortion party. In 2001 Fox was quoted in the Conservative Christian Fellowship prayerbook as saying that the UK's 'pro-abortion laws' should be scrapped. In 2005 Michael Howard almost made abortion a general election issue when, towards to start of the campaign, he told Cosmopolitan magazine 'I believe abortion should be available to everyone, but the law should be changed. In the past I voted for a restriction to 22 weeks, and I would be prepared to go down to 20.'

It is because of examples like this that I am just a little sceptical about the new campaign launched yesterday by the Tory MP Nadine Dorries. A former nurse, Ms Dorries is leading a parliamentary campaign to reduce the upper limit for abortion from 24 weeks to 20 weeks when the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill is debated in the Commons later this month. The last time the law on abortion was amended was in 1990 – given the fact that both medicine and science have advanced significantly one cannot agree that a review of abortion legislation is long overdue.

At present, all legislation on abortion in Britain is considered as a matter of conscience and decided under a free vote. What worries me is that some MPs and campaigners may use the forthcoming debate as a means of polarising attitudes where the issue of abortion is seen only of terms of being a vote winner, or a vote loser. Yesterday’s Daily Mail led on the launch of Ms Dorries’ campaign and will no doubt be a strong advocate of the need for a change in the present law. Britain has a long and enviable record of allowing its elected representatives to make up their own minds in matters of conscience. The danger, as I see it, is that some of Ms Dorries’ colleagues may well be tempted to frame the debate about abortion in such a way that it heralds the first tentative steps to try and establish a political arm for the Christian right in Britain.

Ms Dorries has stated that the campaign is not a religious campaign (yet 6 out of the 10 organisations linked to it are backed by Christian evangelicals) nor, we are told, is it politically motivated. Let’s hope it stays that way.


Nadine Dorries: Playing Politics With Ethics

Last week Conservative MP for Mid Beds Nadine Dorries wrote in her blog: "Being of neither the pro-abortion or pro-life lobby." This was in the context of Nadine arguing that the upper limit for abortions should be reduced from 24 to 20 weeks.

This statement is not strictly true Nadine is it?

Abortion: is it time to change the law?

Whether the time limit on abortion should or should not be lowered is an important topic - far too important for it to ever become a party political issue. This is why Michael Howard's decision to introduce the issue into the 2005 election campaign was so disappointing and why I am hoping that David Cameron's announcement today is not an attempt to gain favour with the anti-abortion lobby.

I personally would welcome a reduction (either to 22 weeks or possibly even 20 weeks). My reasons are based on the fact that more babies born as early as 22 weeks are surviving with the right care. For example leading experts from the University College London Hospitals (UCLH) have found that while in 1983 just 32% of babies born at between 22 and 25 weeks survived, by 2000 their chances had improved to 71%.


What do others think?

Abortion and disability discrimination

An important debate is happening in the House of Lords this week.  An amendment has been tabled to end the discriminatory nature of abortion legislation.  The law currently permits an abortion to be conducted right up to birth, when any disability has been detected, whereas it is a criminal offence to abort an able-bodied fetus after 24 weeks.  Clearly, a case of one law for the able-bodied another for the disabled.  I hope our peers support this important amendment.

Should the Abortion Laws be Liberalised?

Very important debate coming up for the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill - should the abortion laws of the UK become more liberalised or more restrictive?