Why it can only be Miliband

There is one reason why Miliband is the only person who can credibly challenge Brown from within the cabinet.



As he is seen generally as the leader in waiting by many people, if his sole concern was to be leader of the party, then all he has to do is wait till the next Election and replace GB if we lose. The position is virtually his for the waiting.

Therefore, any move ahead of that suggests that his concern is less about personally leading the Labour Party, but about saving it from defeat - or at least minimising the scale of the defeat.

Anyone else going for the role unilaterally - with the exception of John McDonnell who made his intentions very clear a year ago - could be seen as trying to grab his / her moment of glory when in other circumstances s/he would never get the chance to be our leader.

Therefore, it is only Miliband who can be seen as acting selflessly in the interests of the party by offering himself up as an alternative leader?

All of which, incidentally, starts to make a 2009 General Election seem a lot more plausible!

Display: Sort:

Re: Why it can only be Miliband (#1)

This 'leader in waiting' stuff  is hazardous.  Brown was 'leader in waiting', and look how crap he is. Nobody has a god given right to lead the Labour Party, and it is not Miliband's 'for the taking'.

Re: Why it can only be Miliband (#2)

I was talking about perceptions, and that he is 'seen' as the leader in waiting - and that by that argument if his sole intention is to lead the party then his best option is to await a defeat and go for the leadership after a GE defeat - it's the fact that if he were to go for it now, it would be a far braver move than if someone else from within the cabinet went for it.

I totally agree that there should be no coronation of a new leader - that cost Brown a lot of credibility, and is a mistake that must not be allowed to be repeated again.

And of course in any such election I would be supporting McDonnell - the point of this post is that if there is to be a leadership bid from within the Cabinet, only Miliband can credibly present himself as putting party before ego.

THere's more tham Miliband. (#3)

Apparently, John McDonnell is willing to give it a go and wants to stand

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2008/jul/31/labourleadership.gordonbrown

Re: THere's more tham Miliband. (#4)

He only says that he's up for a leadership election any time.  He has no intention of engineering one or seeking to, and has made that clear in several places (including his Comment is Free article in the Guardian today!)