Scottish Labour leadership in context

With Wendy's move on and in the aftermath of Glasgow East, Scottish Labour's attention will shift this week to the election of a new leader of Labour in the Scottish Parliament.

http://thearmchairsocialist.blogspot.com/2008/07/scottish-labour-leadership-in-context.html

I am genuinely (and for a variety of reasons) more interested in a debate around the major issues facing Labour north of the border than in the personalities likely to be involved in the contest and I am therefore trying to keep an open mind and intend to listen to what each of the candidates have to say for themselves before finally making my mind up about who will do the job best. With acting-leader, Cathy Jamieson, a declared runner it remains to be seen whether we will see a dual contests for leader and deputy leader. While I have some concerns that the emergence of joint tickets could actually close down debate on some of the more contentious issues which might benefit from an airing, I do on balance believe that elections for the whole leadership team would be preferable. In addition, to the front-runners, Jamieson, and fellow former ministers - Iain Gray and Andy Kerr, Charlie Gordon and Ken Macintosh have signalled their intention to try and obtain the necessary signatures although I would think their chances of being successful in this endeavour are bound to be slim. As yet we do not know whether Margaret Curran will reprise her interest in either job, and while I hope she does join in, who could blame her if she decides to try and fit in some rest in this recess. Malcolm Chisholm, Davie Stewart, Rhona Brankin and Duncan McNeil would all make interesting candidates in a deputy leadership contests and there is always the possibility that one of the leadership candidates could run for both offices.

There remain a number of outstanding issues from Wendy Alexander's leadership and her leadership campaign, most notably on a referendum, which the contest can hopefully go someway towards resolving. Other matters include, the relationship between the Scottish and the wider UK Party and the role of the leader of the SPLP in relation to the organisation in Scotland and the Scottish Group of the Westminster PLP.

In my view Wendy Alexander's leadership suffered because she did not have the benefit of being able to set out a stall and promote her analysis in a competition before being thrust into the weekly rough and tumble of party politics as covered in the Scottish press and I hope that this time both the organisation and the respective campaigns will see the value in a full and frank discussion about how Labour reconnects with those it seeks to represent in Scotland.

As Glasgow East showed, the Scottish Party must be more than about just listening or 'standing up', it needs to have a clear and progressive agenda about how and why it wants to change Scotland and it must be vocal in its attempts to convince the voters that it has a vision not just an alternative management strategy. Labour in Scotland needs to face up to how far it has fallen in the public estimation and the contrast which people rightly or wrongly see between a confident and united SNP offering policies within the confines of the Scotland Act, which can be both popular and in a few cases genuinely radical and a perception which is being propagated of a tired Labour Party, more interested in fighting amongst itself and offering little in the way of analysis beyond a defence of the union which comes across as doing Scotland down instead of demonstrating the benefits of working together for the good of everyone on this island.

Each of the candidates will be keen to demonstrate that their approach to these questions is the one that should win the confidence of the electoral college and over the coming period I will mull over whether to post my own thoughts on the issues which I think each of the candidates must personally address, in the meantime this piece from yesterday's Scotsman has been giving me some food for thought.

Display: Sort:

Re: Scottish Labour leadership in context (#1)

...now there's a job for Des Browne or Alistair Darling. What Scots Labour needs are heavyweights to take on the wily Salmond who is frankly running rings around Scots Labour and will continue to do so in the foreseeable future. Donald Dewar was parachuted in from Westminster, so should the next Scots Lab Leader. Postpone the election until the Cabinet Reshuffle. However the only problem I can with my suggestion is that we would have to have a by-election in an MSP seat. Can we afford that at the moment, when no seat is safe?

Re: Scottish Labour leadership in context (#2)

I pray that Scottish Labour will pick somebody who's sensible and competent rather than hit the panic button.

Re: Scottish Labour leadership in context (#3)

Your main problem is, who would see being 'exiled' to scotland as a career move?  If you see yourself as a competent Labour politician at junior ministerial level,  would you regard being sent to scotland as a step-up or a step-down.

Throw into that that sending a non-scot is not only suicide but would be seen by the scots as taking the piss and you see the scale of the problem.

You need very skilled, scottish politicians who wish to leave the westminster set-up permanently - to achieve in scotland, bin it and return to westminster re-inforces the SNP argument,  If you go to scotland, you go for good.

Not going to happen is it.  Labour will send wek second rate politicians with little ambition and Caeser Salmond will gobble them up.

Dewar?  Old man.  Salmond will physically wear him down and do it on purpose.

Re: Scottish Labour leadership in context (#4)

Adwilliams134 - do you want to have a think about your last line regarding the late Donald Dewar?

Re: Scottish Labour leadership in context (#11)

My apologies.  I was thinking along several strands at once.  I ment John Reid, who is the only heavyweight Scot who fits the frame.

Re: Scottish Labour leadership in context (#5)

I've never heard anyone in Scotland suggest that one of the MPs should do the job, quite apart from the practical impossibilities of getting them a seat, I can't think of one of them who is up to the job.  I'm afraid the rest of the country is welcome to Alistair Darling!

Re: Scottish Labour leadership in context (#9)

In any case technically the post is leader of Labour in the Scottish parliament. The leader of the Labour Party in Scotland is Gordon Brown just like everywhere else.

Nominations so far (#6)

Nominations received for Leader



Iain Gray MSP nominated by

Claire Baker MSP
Richard Baker MSP
Rhona Brankin MSP
Margaret Curran MSP
George Foulkes MSP
Iain Gray MSP
David Stewart MSP



Cathy Jamieson MSP nominated by

Bill Butler MSP
Malcolm Chisholm MSP
Cathie Cragie MSP
Patricia Ferguson MSP
Marlyn Glen MSP
Rhoda Grant MSP
Hugh Henry MSP
Cathy Jamieson MSP
Cathy Peattie MSP
Karen Whitfield MSP



Nominations received for Deputy Leader


Bill Butler MSP nominated by

Bill Butler MSP
Cathie Cragie MSP
Patricia Ferguson MSP
Marlyn Glen MSP
Cathy Peattie MSP
Elaine Smith MSP


Johann Lamont MSP nominated by

Malcolm Chisholm MSP
George Foulkes MSP

Re: Nominations so far (#7)

Not heard of Lamont, Butler, Gray or Jamieson; not exactly household names, even north of the border I suspect. I've heard of George Foulkes though; but how come he can nominate both Lamont and Gray?

Re: Nominations so far (#8)

He nominated Gray for Leader and Lamont for Deputy Leader

Update (#10)

Sandra Boyack and Helen Eadie nominated Iain Gray.
Helen Murray has nominated Cathy Jamieson.

For the Deputy contest, Karen Whitefield has nominated Bill Butler. Sandra Boyack, Helen Eadie and Elaine Murray nominated Johann Lamont.
http://www.scottishlabour.org.uk/received_nominations