Demutualisation and the Credit Crunch
Why Building Societies are a better model than newly created PLCs - and why we should say so
In all the coverage and comment on the credit crunch it surprises me how little has been said about the impact of the demutualisation of building societies and the consequential free market funding arrangements adopted by the newly created banks. Today's news is all about Bradford and Bingley, another former mutual that has followed a questionable business model once converted to a PLC.
The remaining Building Societies, who still rely heavily on savers for their capital funds to support mortgages, are not struggling in the same way that these banks are. They are impacted by the general state of the economy and the housing market, of course, but not by their funding model.
Those who forced through the demutualisation ballots a decade ago have left us with a poor legacy. The Chairman of Northern Rock when it hit problems was the son of Tory cabinet minister Nicholas Ridley, a comitted de-regulation campaigner just like his Dad. But who really now believes that the problem with the banking sector is too much regulation?
Our Labour values, our Co-operative values, have proven their worth through this sorry episode, but nobody in the Labour movement seems to be saying so.
The remaining Building Societies, who still rely heavily on savers for their capital funds to support mortgages, are not struggling in the same way that these banks are. They are impacted by the general state of the economy and the housing market, of course, but not by their funding model.
Those who forced through the demutualisation ballots a decade ago have left us with a poor legacy. The Chairman of Northern Rock when it hit problems was the son of Tory cabinet minister Nicholas Ridley, a comitted de-regulation campaigner just like his Dad. But who really now believes that the problem with the banking sector is too much regulation?
Our Labour values, our Co-operative values, have proven their worth through this sorry episode, but nobody in the Labour movement seems to be saying so.
Demutualisation and the Credit Crunch | 8 comments (8 topical)
Demutualisation and the Credit Crunch | 8 comments (8 topical)


