Why Listening matters.

Today we are getting a strong committment from the party leadership to listen effectively.

Getting this right matters, and we need to work on ways of improving the listening process, right through from from the door knockers like myself to the inner circles of Government. 

Doing it right will give us the early warning systems we need to deal with problems quietly, rather than in the middle of a media frenzy.  


I suppose that one advantage that I have over some of the relatively new friends I have made in the Labour Party is that I joined only last year, with the succession in doubt, and at the point when the Labour Party was entering one of its periodic episodes of trying to rip itself apart. So whatever I was expecting it didn’t involve any sunlit uplands, or roses.

On the face of it my reason for joining could appear perverse. I was just coming to the end of 10 years of caring for my mother, who suffered from severe dementia following a stroke, and I was pretty disillusioned about the quality of care, the interface between social care and the health service and the whole structure of care funding.

Initially this experience was so bad that it made me seriously doubt that I had been doing the right thing in voting Labour for the last 30 years. It wasn’t until I had researched the background to the problem for several months that I could see that it went back far beyond this Government to the Community Care Act of the 1990’s and to the low tax economy of the 1980’s. This Government certainly deserve some criticism for not having got to grips with the problem over the last 11 years, but like many other things that they have to deal with, it is an enormously complex and challenging issue.

What my MP did, which turned my very real anger into a strong commitment to help him, and also to try and do what I can to strengthen the democratic process, is something very simple. He listened, he thought about what I was telling him, and he accepted that there was a real problem. We have been working together on this now for the best part of 2 years, and I have seen all the delicate background work that he has had to do, and have finally seen the commitment to the Green Paper on Care Funding.

We now, in the wake of the 10p turmoil and the May day massacre, have Gordon’s renewed commitment to listen. It is crucial, but also difficult. One of the other factors that played into my decision to join the party was watching some of the committee sessions on “the Role of the Backbencher”. This was a highly revealing series of interviews which really showed some of the difficulties involved in being an MP. It showed something of the reason why 1997 did not bring about the golden age we all hoped for. A landslide election throws together a crowd of ambitious, intelligent, idealistic people, all hoping to change the world. It gives them very little in the way of training, and the culture of the commons really does not encourage people to ask for support. There is no effective infrastructure to help them to work collectively to identify where problems might exist, and then there is the endless tide of mail. The better and more approachable and effective the MP is the more mail they get.

Getting the Listening right really matters. I do this at the grass roots level. I am on the phones or knocking doors week after week, because I am trying to support my MP in his highly marginal seat. I have set up effective systems for capturing the issues that I am encountering and feeding these to my MP, and I know that his case workers do something similar with all the mail that comes through, but it needs to go beyond that. We need a simple system, which does not make any big demand on the time of MPs or their staff, which allows the collective logging of issues. If we can do this it would give us an effective early warning system, which would flag up potentially dangerous issues whilst they are still small. And then, it we really do have a listening Government this would allow us to deal with matters quietly and carefully, rather than have to do it all in the middle of a media frenzy.




Display: Sort:

Re: Why Listening matters. (#1)

Its not the listening that matters its the doing, and Labour has been a bit slow on the 'doing'. Houses? Get a move on and build them. Energy? Make the committment now and get on with nuclear. Benefits? Crack down on those taking the system for a ride. Get those reforms in now. Crime? Get tougher on those that make life hell for decent people. Do it now.

Re: Why Listening matters. (#3)

What are your suggestions for 'HOW' we make these benefits and crime crackdowns?

Re: Why Listening matters. (#4)

Listening, and having the systems that allow us to pass messages effectively right up through the party does matter, because there a lot of people who were angry enough last week to stay at home or cast their votes against us. 
Canvassing tells me that many of these voted for us in the past and feel let down. They don't actually expect anything better from anyone else, and they still want us to get it right.  
We do need to act, where it is clear what we should do, but in other cases it is better to show that we have understood the problem and are working on it. It is better not to try to kid people that there are instant solutions. Getting the right reponse to some of the complex problems we all face will take time.

Re: Why Listening matters. (#2)

Homer would say "DOH" being disabled and unable to do much I've  a carer my wife, my wife has Spina bifida, looking back through Labour, nope I have no reason to look back I've been in Labour for 38 years.

What could Labour do to help carers now to day, pay them a decent benefit, £48 for looking after somebody 24/7 for £48 is an insult.

Not hard to do, is it so all that you have said means nothing, nothing at all, because Brown thinks we are picking on him now for Little things, he still does not understand if he does not wake up and smell the roses, he will be smelling defeat.

Re: Why Listening matters. (#5)

I am a christian who all his life in the uk have always voted Labour. For the first time this year I found myself considering to vote for the Conservatives. I feel Labour does not accept me anymore as a christian in this country. We try hard to talk through MPs etc. but to no avail on matters that concerns us. I think the extreme wing of the party is bringing intolarance and makes us feel that we are no longer needed in the party. I am not homophobic, but I believe christians must not be criminalise for practising what the bible teaches, I am one of those who take his believes seriously. As much as I believe that people who are gay have the right to thier chosen life style. I also believe a church have a collective right to live as the bible teaches.

If our beloved party can learn to listen and find compromises other than pursuing a divisive agenda that will keep a lot of people including myself in the party. This just one example of the importance of listening. There are people like myself who feel aleinated from the party in this way.

Re: Why Listening matters. (#7)

I don't think people are criminalising homophobia. You can say that homosexuality is wrong for church believers, but there's never the suggestion from churches that people don't have to be gay, once laws banning bigotry against gay people come in. For instance, the law last year didn't say that Roman Catholic charities HAD to give adopted children to gay couples, just that gay couples couldn't be banned from being chosen.


I think that actually, New Labour is often found aligning with piety. Blair encouraged religious funded education. Look at the uproars found within the party involving religion. Brown compromising on embryo research, people concerned about gay marriage and abortion. Secularism ensures neutrality. I believe Christains should be able to say what they want, but not to do whatever they want, based on their beliefs. If a Christain is persecuted by a gay person in the work place, by all means, prosecute them. But someone cannot claim that their beliefs are being infringed upon, if they persecute a gay person. By all means, criticisise it, as much as I disagree with that opinion, but don't expect to claim that it is your right to persecute.

I am not accusing you, of any of the above statements, this is more of an open letter to Christains.

Re: Why Listening matters. (#8)

As much as I believe that people who are gay have the right to thier chosen life style.

Being gay is NOT a "chosen lifestyle".

If Labour has to 'tone down' gay rights, move away from it's broadly pro-choice stance on abortion or speak out against such things as voluntary euthanasia or the new embryology bill in order to satisfy the more extreme Christians, then I'm afraid that's not a price worth paying.

Most people in Labour (left or right) are secularists and that's the way it should stay.