Damn it we need some discipline!

Frankly I’m appalled at the behaviour of Labour’s recent whingers, whiners and the proverbial brigade.

Anyone would think that they were part of the opposition rather than supporters of the government or perhaps they have developed an irrational hatred of Labour councillors and want to be them loose their seats not to mention Ken.

What we need is greater discipline not less. I don’t remember reading in any election handbook how government supporters slagging off the government just before elections helps return the said government at the polls. Now is when Labour needs more support not less. Rupa Huq is offering up her sister tush for the cause. Now that’s commitment.

Still it is no use turning a deaf ear. Even a super loyalist like Akehurst reckons we need to act. So here’s 5 things I think the government should be doing.

1) The government should reverse the 10p tax rate abolition. This should be done now rather than in a years time. Yes it would be difficult (but not impossible) to achieve but it would be the right thing to do. Sure I accept their are good technical reasons to press on but politicians have to deal with the political reality. Increasing tax rates for the poor is not what the Labour government should be doing and taxing people more and giving it back to them in tax credits just creates work for administrators rather than social justice which should be the yardstick by which we operate. When ministers in interviews go on about the great many things Labour have done for the low paid over the last ten years they are right but it also means they know as well the government’s best political idea is not taxing 5 million + of our core voters more just before elections.

2) Straight after the local elections we should have a reshuffle. I don’t think it’s right to name names (not every one wants to do a Wiseman) but if I was doing it it would be pretty brutal. Blood should be reaching up the walls and not confined to the carpet. PPS’s who can’t even resign properly should be the start rather than the end.

3) Parliament should be much more powerful in scrutinizing government. It’s no good having a hissy fit after something has gone through the scrutiny process. Select committees should have substantial staffs and this should also apply to standing standing committees. These staffs should be called the Dunwoody brigade and they should scare the hell out of the people they call to account. Ministers who haven’t thought through the effects of legislation should be cleaning the brown stuff off their smalls rather than thinking they can wing it. Detention for 42 days would be a great idea if it was applied to ministers having their bills scrutinized in parliament.

4) I believe more equal societies are better than the alternative of social division and stunted opportunity. The super rich have done really well over the last decade. They can afford to make a greater contribution so that the rest of us (ie the other 99%) get to keep more of our earnings and the government can tackle the evil that is poverty. We should also let the electorate know this is what we stand for before polling day. Ministers with bland cliches saying they want everyone to get rich will not cut it. Inequality matters.

5) We should press ahead with welfare reforms. Indeed it should be full steam ahead. The DWP doesn’t do a very good job at all in getting people back into work and any socialist worth their salt has to recognise that worklessness is an evil that we need to be unremittingly hard upon. I see no chapter in the Handbook of Social Justice about creating an underclass in receipt of state handouts. If charities and the private sector can do better at getting people into employment then it is imperative they be given the chance. Though there is one important line that I would draw in that I would bar religious groups because as we can see from the education sector they give preferential treatment to their own followers in the provision of services which is totally unacceptable.

http://parburypolitica.wordpress.com/


Display: Sort:

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#1)

Interesting article.

Lets see:
1.Reverse the 10p abolition.
Mr Brown has said no.
So you'll be getting a new Leader then.
Who will it be?

2.Reshuffle?

Good Idea. Smith should go - she's useless.
And Darling.. see the mess he's got Labour in.
And Des Brown is useless.
And Straw has outlived his use
And Balls is: a walking advert of all that's wrong with Labour.

Milliband? No idea.
Promote Frank Field. He's competent.

Can't think of many competent people to replace them with..

3.Parliamentary scrutiny: Agree 100%. But after all it was the Labour Party who cheered the introduction of 10% tax .. so a little more scrutiny and less idiot partisanship - on both sides.

4. Tax the rich.Great.
Start with Hilary and Wedgewood Benn. And the other Labour millioaires. And the Folletts.

The other millionaires will leave the country. Chealsea FC will go bust.

5. Welfare Reform
Agreed. 
As for religious groups, they do an awful lot of good. fornothing.

It will not happen cos you have built a client state of dependees and civil servants dishing out allowances.

On the basis of the above, Gordon Brown has to go.. or nothing will be done.





Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#2)

good article will, your right we need discipline and after the election we should reshuffle the cabinet.

john

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#8)

Great article wiseman! Funny how Westminster always manages to kick the Party in the b***s exactly at the same time the local elections come around. There has to be a reshuffle on May 7th; the appointment of a DPM to bolster Gordons leadership; a night of the long knives to rid the Cabinet and Govt of oh so tired faces; a peace pact with the Blairites and Brownites until the next election is called ie gagging of Ed Balls and Charles Clarke. And going back to the first point, a bit more recognition of the activists at grass roots who are getting a bit fed up with the internecine squabbling at Westminster. And promises of measures to redress the 10p cut in the Autumn Budget Statement, although I fear that we've already alienated many of our low income supporters..

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#9)

...that should have been wilparbury.

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#3)

Actually, the pilot schemes the government ran showed that the DWP is better at getting people back to work than the private sector, charities etc.  This is depite the fact that the DWP was generally landed with the long term "problem cases", and the private sector was allowed to cherry pick.  This "welfare reform" is driven by ideology, not "results"... and it's an ideology that is alienating our core vote at a time when the Tories are doing a very good job of targeting the "floating" voter by managing to resemble a sensible political party rather than a bunch of cats in a sack.

And yes, "we" need more discipline, but as far as I can see it's the so-called "Blairites" who are causing the trouble, and I'm not sure how much they can be described as "we", since they seem to be utterly hostile to everything the Labour Party has stood for throughout it's existence.

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#4)

And yes, "we" need more discipline, but as far as I can see it's the so-called "Blairites" who are causing the trouble, and I'm not sure how much they can be described as "we", since they seem to be utterly hostile to everything the Labour Party has stood for throughout it's existence.

What a load of guff. The Blairites have been fine - it's the Brownites who have split up into various factions and declared war on each other. Balls being the chief culprit.

Seems to me like you just wanted to get in a little dig at the Blairites for no apparent reason.

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#5)

And how does your article contribute to the discipline of not slagging off the government?

It seems as though you're slagging off Labour as much as anyone.

You should also read Rupa Huq's blog more carefully. She is commenting on Matthew Norman's suggestion for Gordon to marry Konnie, and actually thinks that "the advice to ditch Sarah must be a joke". 

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#6)

Charles Clarke is a Brownite? Frank Field is a Brownite? You need some perspective, mate. Or did I hit a nerve?

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#7)

Frank Field certainly isn't a Blairite. And Charles Clarke is a loose cannon who fires at anyone, in any direction (including Blair).

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#10)

A fair few at ConservativeHome would welcome Frank Field into the Tory Party!  Certainly not a Brownite either. An enigma?

Re: Damn it we need some discipline! (#11)

Fair enough, Frank Field is just an egomaniac.  But you're reaching in pretending that Charles Clarke isn't a Blairite.

Anyway, these are marginal issues.  What really depresses me to see are Labour supporters putting down something like point 5 above - it's just not true that the DWP does a bad job of getting people in to work, it's not true that the private sector is better at it, and it's not true that there are large number of people who don't want to work (I'll qualify that - the likes of Derek Conway's son obviously don't want to work, as do many other members of the "idle rich").