The credit crunch and the BNP

According to Jon Cruddas (Tuesday's Evening Standard)the far-Right BNP is busy exploiting the present economic crisis and could easily end up winning seats in the European Parliament for the first time.

Jon Cruddas has long pointed out that one reason for the growing support for the BNP has been its ability to respond to and exploit genuine local grievances - the credit crunch will only end up exacerbating these issues and could help turn more people toward the far-right. It is sobering to remember that in recent local elections the BNP has continued to gain seats in east London and Stoke-on-Trent and picked up enough elsewhere to hold 46 council seats in England. This of course follows the dramatic 2002 local election successes in the North of England and a 4.9 per cent showing in the Euro elections in 2004. For the first time ever in this country, an openly racist party has sustained the support of more than one in 20 British voters over several contests.

I believe that the BNP is evidence of a new challenge in British politics. In the past the battle ground (sometimes literally) of left vs right politics centred on our inner-cities – this is no longer the case. The BNP has begun to develop a network of suburban supporters, people who are openly willing to admit not only to supporting a racist and bigoted political party but to doing so with pride and patriotic fervour. If the trends of the past few years continue continue, the BNP may well make the type of breakthrough that Jon Cruddas is signalling and it will then be far more difficult to reverse than to stop it before it occurs.

What Britain needs is a broad anti-fascist coalition, a new coalition of the willing. This broadest possible coalition against the BNP must be constructed nationally, regionally and locally. It needs to involve trade unions, black, Asian and minority ethnic communities, faith groups, lesbian and gay groups and every other community threatened by the rise of the far right.

Display: Sort:

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#1)

The problem of course is the BNP is also exploiting the "plague on both your houses" argument.

We're also stuck in the biggest fall in stocks since 1929, we have to be very careful at how to deal with the BNP and the present strategy of simply not engaging with them is still working.

Indeed, similarities drawn with Hitler's NSDAP at the time, when most parties ignored him, failed to gain proper power. It was only when they started to enagage with him openly that he had a large-scale platform to stand on and begin to seduce the population and electorate.

 To be honest, the numbers are still incredibly small, and a number of "Further Right" parties [Though personally I prefer to leave the BNP in it's own category due to it's socialistic policies also...]

They are rising all over Europe, in Austria and Northern Italy for example, they're becoming the dominant force. It seems, to me at least, people are no longer tolerating various "Liberal" tendancies and the perceptions that are becoming well entrenched within elements of society who's explinations by the liberal and indeed the left, are no longer adding up in the minds of voters.

For example, society isn't broken according to people from the left and liberal persuations but there are problems of increasing feelings of lawlessness and crime simply going unreported.

I only really need to cite the case of Shaun Dykes from Derby, when a crowd gathered and goaded him as he prepared to throw himself off a building, and then gathered to take pictures of his dead body on their mobile phones.

Now, that's just an example, an extreme example and folks know the likelyhood of any of those people being found, caught and got anything bar a strong telling off is so slim as to be laughable.

People, quite simply, are scared. So they turn to parties that promise to bring back the blue coated bobby on the beat, the ones who will allow the police to operate as they please to bring crime down rather than be "fully accountable" via paperwork.

Ontop of this is the problem of Nick Griffin. Since he took over the party it's gone through a transformation.

Association to Combat 18 are gone, a lot of it's racist policies are toned down, replaced with policies on the genuine worry of the rapid rise of extreme islam in this country [Wahabist as opposed to the more mundane Sufi islam which has been in the UK since the 1700's and is fairly well integrated historically and culturally in the UK]

Couple this with the addition of every policy of the BNP being voted on by members as opposed to think tanks, and it slowly becomes more and more attractive to people who wouldn't normally find themselves attracted to political parties find themselves interested in the BNP because it's structure is more democratic than the "Big Three".

We also live in a free society and it means that sometimes we have to accept bitter pills and swallow them. We tolerated people like Moqtadr Al Sadr for years and his viritol was much worse than some of the stuff the BNP officially comes out with these days and ti does seem a fairly reasonable party to support.

This is added to when activists and standees are in full buisness suits and look professional whenindeed in my area, the labour councillor who won by just 123 votes turned up in a tatty T-shirt and jeans shows just how serious their underground activities can be.

In order to beat the Nationals it's simple. We need to encourage professionalism and even a dress code on the candidates of all parties, regardless of position and get back to talking about local issues which concern people. Not selling some "Better Britain" idea.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#41)

We're also stuck in the biggest fall in stocks since 1929

Umm... actually it's only the biggest stock falls since 2003. FTSE was 6900 in 2000 and hit 3287 in March 2003. This time the high was 6700 in Oct 2007 and it is not 4500.

So stop the hyperbole, eh?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#51)

I have seen some similar claim about stocks and 1929 somewher on the BBC site,  but I think it's actually to do with monetary value as opposed to points.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#2)

Hear hear.

I was speaking to my self-admitting bourgeois UMP supporting French friend the other day, who is constantly worried that the FN will gain even more support in France. And it made me think how much worse the situation is over there, considering we worry when the BNP gains council seats.


If the BNP was criticising Islam on an anti-theist track, as well as other religions, I would agree on that issue. But they criticise Islam because what they are trying to say is that Muslim=Brown, to drive fear into people's minds that our Asian community wants to blow us up. Many of my secular Muslim friends have gotten much grief, because of BNP tactics. This is key. Islam is their supposed top grief, because it is the area where they can most twist people's fears. They don't argue about misogyny in religion (how can they when their top candidates say women enjoy rape?), or about anti-semitism (I don't even wonder why that is). Their arguments pretty much consist of "Uuugggh. That mosque looks funny. And so does them Muslim's food." My Muslim friends laugh it off, and so do most reasonable people. But the British Nazi Party gains legitemacy from papers like the Daily Mail creeping in articles about an "Islamic invasion", or "Muslim invasion", which as usual carries a great deal of xenophobic innuendos, but then they act piously suprised when the BNP does so well.


Then there is that elephent in the room: immigration. The government has rightly made the case or the economic benefits of immigration, and the British people are reasonable. Most know that immigration is good for our economy, but they don't want to see adverse effects on housing or wages and services. Now, most Poles will probably go back, as I note my Polish friends send most of their money back to families, to build up the Polish economy. The government doesn't want to appear weak on national security though, which I think has resulted in a crappy asylum policy.

I think we do need to end state sponsered multiculturalism through faith schools, which encourages segregation, and gives weight to the BNP's constant incinuation that Muslims and the ethnic minority community are an "other".

In the long term, some form of industrial dmocracy may be helpful. Why? Because wages are suppressed in low-paid jobs, which many will blame on immigrants. But what if immigrants and British workers fought together for fair wages?

The most important issue, is housing. Gordon electrified the base, and tapped into a long worried swing voting group worried about housing, with his promise for 3 million new homes to be built. Maybe Brown can be radical again if we weather the current economic woes. But it needs to be our biggest concern for the next 2 years. I think we should use the funds generated from right-to-buy to build more social housing. It could give the construction industry some work, it would show the London and South-East swing voters we care, and it would show this to our base as well. What's more, it would rattle the BNP.


Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#3)

As some of you know from other things that I have written, I have quite a bit of direct experience of the BNP.  I know BNP voters, I know BNP members & activists and I know a couple of quite high ranking ones in the Greater Manchester area.  With a couple of exceptions at voter level none are friends I might hasten to add,  but I work alongside them, live amongst them, drink in the same pubs etc etc.  They know who I am, they know I will oppose them wherever and whenever I can.  I have been attacked by their 'proxies' twice and they know I'm not scared of them and will face them off wherever and whenever I see them no matter how many of them there are.

Unfortunately it must be said that most politicians on the other hand have no direct experience of them, speak total BLX about them and make themselves look stupid as a result.

First off - and I have met direct denial from Labour councillors over this - you have to accept that most BNP voters are former-Labour voters or would be that way inclined in different times. The vast bulk are white, skilled working class and are fairly 'savvy' with what is going on in their particular area.

Next you have got to accept that the vast bulk of BNP voters are not dullards, do not have psycopathic tendencies, are not football hooligans, are not homophobes, are not anti-semites and with the exception of asian muslims are not racist and are not nazis.  Accusing them of this offends them greatly and just reinforces their beliefs.  It also starts people around them who know them wondering whether the established  parties are in fact useless.  I can introduce you to carribbean immigrants who came here in the 60's & 70's who vote BNP.  I can introduce you to an openly gay couple who, because of intolerance shown by their muslim neighbours, vote BNP and I can even introduce you to a work colleague and fellow union member who is asian muslim but has secularised his and his family's lives to such a degree he wears an England shirt, comes the pub to watch 'footie' and insists his wife and daughter do not wear hajibs, kemises etc but western clothes.  He votes BNP as well.

The 'No Platform' policy does not work.  Although it is the policy of all the main parties - including Plaid & the SNP - in certain parts of the country it is being ignored,  mainly at council election level, because the candidates know each other personally.  If you want to have a 'No Platform' policy you have got to enforce it ruthlessly and withdraw the whip where necessary.

40-odd councillors is no big deal.  It's the hundreds of second and third places that are the problem.   Like I said earlier, on the whole they appeal to disenchanted traditional labour voters and those votes lost to second and third places are allowing other parties to take Labour seats.   If the BNP get much bigger,  they will start to affect Parliamentary seats to such an extent that Labour won't just have to worry about swings to conervative,  but erosion of their base by the BNP at the same time.

The only way you are going to stop the BNP is take them on head-on at the hustings, in the streets and on things like Question Time. 

Underneath that you are going to have to make sure that Equality Laws are exactly that and there is no 'reverse-discrimination' (favouritism) going on.

Then you are going to have to undermine their core and the only way you will do that is to bring in some good old-fashioned traditional Labour polices.  The twio that would have the biggest impact are more Council houses (as Cruddas has rightly pointed out) and guarenteed NHS dental treatment for all in your own PCT.   It's Bred & Butter like that that will destroy the BNP more than anything.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#4)

Underneath that you are going to have to make sure that Equality Laws are exactly that and there is no 'reverse-discrimination' (favouritism) going on.

Can you provide any examples (with links, not anecdotal evidence) of this happening? 'Reverse-discrimination' is as illegal as traditional discrimination.

Accepting that this is widespread goes a long way to legitimising the BNP's agenda and actually feeds their vote.

Spot on with the last paragraph though.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#5)

Young lad where I work.  Is a Special Constable and an RNLI volunteer.  Has a stable relationship and has a mortgage.   Fine upstanding member of the community in fact.

Has applied to join the regular Police Force in our area for the last 2 recruitment drives.  Both times has got through to the interview stage and passed all the tests (he is a Special Constable anyway so that helps) and both times he has been knocked back on the grounds of ethnicity quotas.   That one good enough for you?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#6)

Ethnicity quotas in recruitment are illegal so your mate should have no trouble in winning at employment tribunal if that is really what happened.

I asked for examples referenced in writing with a link. Examples of "a mate down the pub" are of no value and more likely to be inaccurate.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#7)

I have family in North Wales (well with a name like Williams....),  go on the internet,  look for www.dailypost.co.uk,  trawl through their situations vacant and you will find loads of jobs - in particular Anglesey (Ynys Mon)  and Gwynedd where you must be a Welsh Speaker.  Some are even only advertised in Welsh and include local fgovernment, local NHS etc.

Then,  and any one from the Greater Manchester area will back this up,  get a copy of the Oldham Chronicle or vist their website.  You will quite often find adverts - particularly for health workers and primary school teaching assistants - where one of the caveats is must have a south asian language.

Is that not ethnic quotas?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#8)

No, those are jobs which require a particular skill.

Seems sensible that if the job requires interacting in a certain language that applicants should speak that language.

Ethnicity is something which cannot be changed. Speaking a language is not.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#9)

There is no requirement for any teaching asistant in England to be able to speak anything other than English.  To say otherwise panders to the BNP.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#10)

Oh and I nearly forgot.  The lad in question?  They took his partner.  Even though he out-performed her in all the tests and he is a Special but she wasn't good enough,  she did best out of the females who didn't have to do as well in some of the tests.

Is that not discrimination on the grounds of sexuality?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#11)

As above, discrimination or quotas in recruitment are unlawful. I'd advise your friend take it tribunal if those are the facts.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#12)

There is no requirement or you think there should be no requirement?

There obviously is a need, else those adverts would not be placed.

Unless maybe you think that small children should be excluded from learning because of where they have come from?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#13)

I know for a fact that up here in the North West kids from the asian communities who are third generation immigrants are turning up at schools for their first day unable to speak english and never having come into contact with a 'white' child. (my sister is a teacher)

That is wrong and after 11 years of a Labour government that prides itself on multiculturalism and integration is wholly unacceptable.  What's worse is there does not seem to be any policy to alter it.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#15)

I ageee that this is bad. The problem is that they don't provide proper English classes for immigrants and ethnic minorities. They just dump them somewhere and let them fester, unable to integrate because they cannot speak the language and are not given adequate chance to learn it. Now whether non-English speakers should be allowed to immigrate to Engand is another matter, and a massive can of worms, but once they are here they should be given the opportunity to learn English.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#18)

I doubt very much that third generation immigrants have not a word of English, and that's why I'm afraid you'll have to do better than anecdotal "my sister is a teacher" stories.

Nonetheless, I agree that policies are not in place to address the situation.

In the meantime, how does removing TAs who speak the relevant language help the situation or the children?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#23)

Tell you what,  we'll dispense with the 'anecdotal stories'  & my sister is a teacher bit.  E Mail Phil Woolas - the MP for Oldham East & Saddleworth.  His consituency is one of the ones that is having these problems.  he has said so publicly (and been harangued for it by some quarters) many times.  He'll talk to you about integration problems in his constituency along with the refusal of some parts of the community to integrate.

And he was perfectly right to say what he said about marrying cousins.  His new position, if he can stamp his authority on it with out the PC brigade being their usual numpty selves,  is not only right up his street but he will do very well with it.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#47)

Why would I want to communicate with that ****bag? I don't need to hear about integration problems from a rabble rouser like Woolas, thanks, I haven't been on another planet for the last twenty years and am aware of the barriers to integration both within immigrant communities and indigenous communities.

That marrying cousins causing disease thing is a load of crap by the way. Genetically and biologically speaking, utter rubbish. Just feeding prejudices again.

And once again with going on about the mythical "PC brigade", you feed straight into the hands of the BNP. Well done.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#14)

'Discrimination' on grounds of language is perfectly reasonable. You wouldn't make an Arabic speaker  an English teacher. You wouldn't let someone who only speaks Greek be in charge of customer services in Sainsburys. You wouldn't let a non-Welsh speaker have a job that requires them to be fluent in Welsh.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#16)

Discrimination on grounds of language whereby someone working in the normal work place in England- such as school, doctors etc - is denied a job because they cannot speak a foreign language is not helping the immigrant populatuion to integrate and is reinforcing the belief of them being outsiders.

We are hijacking the actual reason for this thread.  I think perhaps we should start a seperate subject along the lines of 'What is Discrimination And Is There Any Justification In Revers Discrimination And/Or Quotas.'

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#17)

The fact is that you have some children entering school, often recent migrants, who do not speak English. They may have only been in the country a few days.

You think the teacher and assistant should just stand there and talk to them in English and hope they pick it up in a few years?

Obviously a more intelligent approach to integration is needed, but getting rid of the frontline TAs who may be able to help kids into the system is hardly the answer.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#19)

I was talking about 3rd Generation.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#22)

Who cares what you were talking about? Do you know for a fact where the children have come from that are going to be supported by the TAs? Do you know each and every one of them individually?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#20)

You think the teacher and assistant should just stand there and talk to them in English and hope they pick it up in a few years.

On Anglesey,  all primary schools with the exception of the one that caters to the nearby RAF base, are welsh only.  Every lesson is done in welsh.  The teachers only speak welsh to the kids.  This is increasing in commonality across North West Wales and is startinf to become fashionable in South Wales now as well.  In some parts it is now entirely welsh-speaking up to 6th form level.  


So if they can do this in Wales (and hats off to them),  then ity should be perfectly possible to do this with the English language in England.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#21)


What about if you haven't had any Welsh at all and start at the school having just arrived in Anglesey aged, say, 13? All the lessons are in Welsh and they provide no support for you? And expect you to keep up?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#24)

That's correct.  They get no support.  They are expected to enrol in an evening class, weekends and summer school etc to learn 'Cymraeg'.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#25)

" No, those are jobs which require a particular skill."

The Oldham one maybe, but not the Welsh. The only people in Wales who do not understand english are newly arrived from abroad and don't speak Welsh either. Chances are their Polish is perfect...

Williams is right. The welsh language requirement is disguised racism.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#26)

Despite personally being English, my family are Welsh.  I actually support the 're-Welsification' of Wales - it is a good thing. Plaid for example have an asian muslim councillor who speaks Welsh and the children of immigrants who have settled in Welsh speaking areas now speak Welsh (apparently kids pick it up pretty quickly if that's all they are exposed to) . I was using it as an example and saying if the Welssh can do it then there's no reason why the English in England can't do the same thing.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#27)

Disguised racism in what way? What a lot of nonsense. Jobs in Welsh-speaking workplaces can't require fluency in Welsh on a job description?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#28)

You seem remarkbly naive if you don't mind me saying.  Jobs in certain parts of Wales including local authority jobs such as teachers in those areas - are only open to applicants fluent at both written and spoken levels of Welsh and have been for some years.   If the English (of which I'm one) hadn't spent donkeys years trying to stamp it out,  they wouldn't be in a position now where they are having to stamp it back in again.

The Welsh language has 'positive-protection' under the same EU laws that cover Catalan in Catalonia and Basque in the Basque regions.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#30)

I don't understand your point. Are you saying that the EU should not foster regional minority languages?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#31)

I don't quite understand what williams's point is there.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#33)

The point is that in North West Wales school children are forced to speak and use Welsh.  That is good and correct.  So in England why are they not doing the same in our schools?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#37)

It is not good and correct if they have no systems for integrating children who arrive in the community knowing no Welsh, to help them at least initially until they are confident in the language.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#42)

Yes but from their point of view,  no one has to move to Wales.  This policy incidentally is Assembly policy and was Parliamentary policy before that.  Therefore it is Labour policy.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#45)

No one has to move to Wales? No one has to move anywhere, if you include being killed as a valid alternative.

And children don't usually have much say in where they move to.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#46)

Well take it up with Gordon Brown then,  or if you think it's a devlved matter, with the Asembly's Labour/Plaid Coalition.  You will get exactly nowhere,  but if it's the Assembly you take it up with their response will be in both languages.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#48)

Why would I take it up with anyone? You brought Wales into this thread, not me.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#49)

I used Wales as an example regarding 3rd generation Asian immigrant kids turning up at school in Oldham unable to speak English and instead of making them learn it,  we were helping them not bother to learn it by providing teachers that speak their grandparents native language.

Whereas in the welsh parts of Wales,  they only speak welsh in schools and 'incomer' children have no option other than to speak welsh and those that can't have to learn it after school, at weekends and during holidays but learn it they will and use it they will. 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#50)

How do you know we are "them not bother to learn it by providing teachers that speak their grandparents native language."

Firstly, you referred to TAs, not teachers.

Secondly, you don't know whether those TAs translate all their lessons, or whether they are there to just help with the first few weeks, or whether they have to know the language just for emergencies.

What happens in Wales is not only irrelevant, but also a poor comparison, because if an English-only child needs urgent help, they can communicate with their staff in English in Anglesey, whereas a child in Manchester who knows no English is potentially at danger if they have nobody in the school with whom they can contribute in the case of an emergency. And it is not the fault of the child that they cannot speak English.

Plus, I don't believe you that any third generation immigrants cannot understand English.


Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#62)

As I said earlier, we're talking 5 year olds here who have been brought up in a closed community.  Speak with Phil Woolas MP. Fascinating bloke.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#63)

I can believe it, but it must be very rare. Evidently more has to be done to reach out to these people to give them more opportunity to learn the language.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#64)

And you know for a fact that it is these people who the TAs are being recruited to work with? Or is it just a few anecdotal stories here and there with no real effect on anything else?

Personally, I'd rather eat my own foot than talk to Phil Woolas and I wouldn't believe anything he told me either.

 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#68)

Being as the jobs are advertised in the esteemed Oldham Chronicle,  along with the south asian language caveat,  I think it's a fair bet.  Who else would they be for?  The dinner lady?

Personally I don't like an awful lot of Woolas's politics - in particular his openly pro-war stance,  but on the issues of race - in particulr the problems regarding integration of the asian muslim community in his ward (which includes Glodwick, of the riot 'fame'),  I think he is spot-on.  Most of the asian community in his constituency do as well - it's their block vote that keeps him in his seat.  One of his sidekicks - Mo Azzam is another good guy who supports what he says as well and the former mayor Riaz Ahmed.  It's bizarre that in the aftermath of the Gulf War,  he kept his share of the muslim vote.  That's how well he is liked.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#73)

What do you think about another outspoken MP on this issue, Ann Cryer?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#74)

I think she is right to say what she says as well.  There is far to much 'fear' of being seen to be racist if you say something that a minority objects to.  If what is said is true then it needs saying and it needs dealing with.  Multiculturalism may have worked in other parts of the country,  but in the North West particularly in Oldham, Burnley, Bolton, Blackburn, Bradford, etc - the former great industrialised mill towns - it has failed.   At the bottom end of the social scale there is virtually no contact between the differing ethnic groups.  They live on seperate estates, have seperate local shops,  and schools are heavily polarised to one ethnic group or the other. 

This polarisation has led to parallel-culturalism as opposed to plural or multi.

In Oldham, great strides are being made to overcome this by for example, making kids attend a school in the 'other area' for one day a week,  inter-school sports days where the teams are half from one school half from the other etc etc to try to get more communication and understanding,  but it doesn't help when half the parents - from both sides - are opposed to it.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#75)

Absolutely.

Multiculturalism to me, reflects the worst elements of individualism. Polyculturalism on the other hand, reflects the diversity which has always been an important part of the Labour party and the labour movement. It was the trade unions who have inspired diversity across the globe.

The whole point of polyculturalism, should be to bring the barriers of socio-economic background crashing down. My friends who are religious are generally progressive, mainly due to them jumping over social barriers. Repression, i.e. segregation, will lead to peversion and extremism. 

Ironically, despite the cries of Nick Cohen, it is the left of the Labour party who make the best arguments about how say, veils are a symbol of repression and segregation. Ann Cryer and Linda Riordan for instance. This isn't just on domestic issues. On the issue of extremism in Iraq, it is the left that are coming up with ideas to solve the mess we're in: Dave Anderson, Harry Barnes, Ann Clwyd etc.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#76)

I met Nick Cohen once.  I didn't like him.  I have to say - and I'm probably going to get slammed here - that in certain areas we have got to force the issue regarding integration, by law if necessary.

Full face covering has got to be stopped.  In order to attempt to stop forced marriages marrying out of the country has got to be stopped.  Postal voting has got to be reigned in.  Asian women in deprived areas have got to be reached, that means posters in surgeries, and in public places and all over the streets if needs be.  Imams have got to be recruited from the muslim population inside this country and not imported and the kKoran used in this country in Mosques and madrassas has got to be in English (or Welssh), but definately not Arabic.  We have got to make the integration of the asian-muslim population a massive priority and that integration has got to be westernised or things in the North West wil not get any better

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#77)

Only part I will slam is "Koran has to be in English" - From my own muslim friends the only English language versions of the Koran are those translated by Westeners specifically to understand the religion.

The Koran has to be in Arabic as that is how Islam works and that is what the Prohpet Mohammed wrote it in. Might I suggest a new chain of posts, seeing as these are becoming increasingly squashed?

I also, personally favour the Persian Hijab [Seen here: http://articleinspector.com/images/persian-women.jpg ]

Which are much more open and like wearing little more than a hat for a woman in church or out and about.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#78)

Christians use the bible in the language of the country they are in, hence why the bible in UK is in english.

To say that the Koran should remain in arabic everywhere is prehistoric arrogance.   The message of the Koran should reach the people n the language of their country.  An asian muslim, born in the UK, is Britsh through and through.  Arabic is not her/his language. 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#79)

My reply to Mike Ion's piece.

Why is Labour so afraid of the BNP?

 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#29)

I sometimes get the feeling that people who attack things to do with language, race and ethnicity for being 'too PC' are often guilty of overdoing the political correctness in the other direction. How is it possibly racist to demand fluency in Welsh from applicants for jobs that actually require it?

It's a bizarre argument and its logical conclusion is that everybody should be forced to speak English as a first language, no matter who they are, where they live and where they come from. 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#32)

No Otware,  in parts of North West Wales Welsh is the first language.  For an awful lot of jobs there is no requirement for any language except Welsh and some require that you have English and Welsh.  Even Tescos Customer Services in Holyhead (or Caergybi as it is now more correctly being referred to) speak Welsh.  The councils speak Welsh,  alll forms come with a Welsh side and an English side,  all the palce names are now both in Welsh and English  with the newer signs having the English underneath in smaller letters.  Street names are in the process of being converted to Welsh etc etc etc

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#35)

"How is it possibly racist to demand fluency in Welsh from applicants for jobs that actually require it?"

Since Welsh is only taught in Welsh schools, then if it is a BOGUS requirement in a job it precludes everyone who isn't welsh. It is a way of saying non-welsh need not apply. 

The relevant question is "how many actually jobs require welsh?". Take three towns that I visit often Denbigh, Ruthin and Wrexham. Line up ALL the people in those towns that speak and understand ONLY welsh and how long will the line be? None of them are more than 10 miles from England. I've yet to met anyone in those towns who doesn't speak english.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#36)

It is a way of saying non-welsh need not apply. 

No it isn't. My father-in-law learned Welsh when he moved there for work.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#39)

The correct thing to do.  Well done him.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#40)

That's North East Wales.  Try Anglesey, western Gwynedd,  down round the beacons etc.  You'll find people who go days without speaking or even having the need to speak English.  In fact,  ask any of the Labour AM/MPs etc in that neck of the woods what their chances of winning a seat are if they can't speak welsh.  Remarkably reduced is the answer they'll give.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#43)

"That's North East Wales"

That's right, but I'm far more likely to work there than Anglesey. So, why should I be precluded from a job in an english speaking area just because I don't speak welsh? Nobody else around there speaks welsh either.

I suppose I could learn a few stumbling phrases of welsh, but that is just tokenism and I would still not be a welsh speaker.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#44)

The rules differ from council to council and area to area.  Obviously where there is a higher level of 'welshness' the requirement to protect it is greater.  Most of the people from Llandudno eastwards speak with a sort of scouse accent.  Once you get to Conwy (formerly Conway) heading west, it becomes more and more welsh 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#34)

Reading some of the stuff in here... I am glad the Pakistani population in my area is very well integrated! I have yet to meet one from the quarter where they live that does not speak decent, if thickly accented, English. An accent which diminishes with each new generation.

I also note the BNP, in an attempt to gather more votes, now has an "Amnesty" on all families who migrated here during the 50's-60's-70's "waves" as 'British' or 'integrated enough to be British'. Indeed it has, last I knew of, two black councilors in Stoke-On-Trent.

Interestingly, and I strongly suspect "foul hands" here, is this article: http://www.burtonmail.co.uk/burtonmail-news/displayarticle.asp?id=305032

 I did a smidgen of my own investigating and spoke to some people in the area and discovered something incredibly interesting with these posters leading me to suspect that they were not placed there by Muslim hands.

All of them were in English. Every last one. Not a single one in Urdu, Punjabi, or any other language.

While in the Easter Sunday/Ramadan parade, held every year in the town was the usual mixture of Urdu and English.

Which, personally, leads me to beleive that they were placed up there purely to inflame feelings against the moderate and tolerant Muslim population which has, aside from a couple of problems lived quietly and well within the town next to the Polish and English community.

Personally I'd strongly suggest it was possibly activists of a certain fringe party which has now declared it's interest in gaining seats in this area.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#38)

The BNP fringe and some of it's hangers on - particularly the 'International Third Position' (not something in the Kama Sutra I may add)  are well known for putting up posters, leaving leaflets on buses etc that at first glance appear to have come from Islamic fundementalist groups in an attempt to destabilise an area.  If it provokes racial tensions it distracts voters from the real isues of the day and allows the more maleable to be manipulated.

Certain organised football hooligan gangs such as the Oldham Fine Young Casuals,  Burnley Suicide Squad and in that neck of the woods Stoke's Naughty Forty are also adept at this form of propoganda dispersal at street level leaving leaflets in pubs, waiting rooms etc etc.

****Organised football hooligan gangs,  although 'affiliated' to certain clubs are not part the proper supporter element and their behaviour is not tolerated by the clubs themselves.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#52)

Ad

You seem to have your heart in the right place but there is stuff you come out with that is way off the mark.  You have claimed that the police operate ethnicity quotas in its recruitment and that 3rd generation immigrants arrive at school not speaking English and then do not need to learn English.  Both claims have no basis in reality.  Get a grip.  Maybe you should become a school governor or get involved with your local Labour Party and then on the Local Government Committee. 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#53)

Mathew,  If you don't believe 3rd generation children arrive at school unable to speak english, I respectfully suggest you speak with Phil Woolas MP (Labour) for Oldham East and Saddleworth.  He will assure you it's true.  Not very common, but true none the less it does happen.  As for the lad where I work who was knocked back twice for the Police it was actually because he was male and they needed more females.  Apparently they,  the Fire Brigade and certain sections of the Armed Forces are allowed to impose certain restrictions in certain areas.  In the Police's case they are allowed to 'ration' places so that they can try to represent the breakdown of the community from which they recruit. 

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#54)

In the Police's case they are allowed to 'ration' places so that they can try to represent the breakdown of the community from which they recruit.

Can you provide a link to back that up? I'm afraid otherwise it has as much substance as "my mate's a copper and he told me..."

I'm afraid it's crap.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#55)

"You have claimed that the police operate ethnicity quotas in its recruitment"

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6902545.stm

 

  • The Home Office has set a target of having 7% of ethnic minority recruits by 2009
  • Targets were set after the Macpherson report into the death of Stephen Lawrence in 1999, to make the police service more representative.
  • Ethnic minority police numbers rose to 3.7% in 2005/06 but should have reached 4% in 2004

 

 If 7% is not a quota, then what is it?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#56)

A target. That means they want to have 7% EM recruits, not that they are allowed to reserve 7% of recruit places for EMs.

They can try and achieve the 7% target by advertising in The Voice or whatever else they think might help get more applicants, but they are not, repeat not, allowed to practise quotas or apply positive discrimination in the actual process of selecting candidates.

Is that clear?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#58)

as I have already said e10,  I meant he was knocked back because he was male not because of ethnicity

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#59)

The same rules apply.

I'm afraid you have either been misled or the employer was acting unlawfully and should be taken to tribunal.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#60)

And all women short lists for prospective MPs?

The fact that women are NOT allowed to join the Infantry as combat soldiers, or Armoured Regiments as tank crews?

And I've just spoken to him and it was because they allocated x number of places for men and y number of places for women.  Because x was full,  they couldn't give him one of y places.  Which is why his girlfriend got in and he didn't even though he got better marks and was already a 'Special' whereas she was rejected to be a 'Special' when they both went into that a year before.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#61)

If that is the situation then he may well have a case.

I think the armed forces cases certainly are open to challenge on grounds of discrimination.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#69)

"I meant he was knocked back because he was male not because of ethnicity" yet you wrote "Both times has got through to the interview stage and passed all the tests (he is a Special Constable anyway so that helps) and both times he has been knocked back on the grounds of ethnicity quotas."

yeah, easy mistake isn't it to confuse ethnicity with gender?

I think it is more likely that you tried to get away with a lie and got caught out. You have no credibility whatsoever.


Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#70)

No,  I went back and asked him.  Any problem with that?

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#57)

Thank you FV

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#66)

You're welcome.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#65)

I don't agree completely with AD's views on this matter. But he is absolutely right that we need to make social housing, and fixing dentistry top priorities.

Language is always the biggest barrier. At my school, many of the second generation immigrants are more English than those whose family have always lived here.

The problem is that we often assume that the BNP voters are chavvy football hooligans, in a snobbish way. And while it may be difficult for us to believe that any black people would consider voting BNP (btw Angry Voter, there aren't any black members of the BNP, there is only one ethnic minority member, a Turkish counciller in Barking and Dagenham), many on East London estates have told UAF activists that if they didn't have mixed race children, they would definitely vote BNP.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#67)

well done jk,  back on topic.  The BNP do have some sort of parrallel organisation though for "non ethnic Northern Europeans". It has some sikhs and hindus in it.  And as for the turkish geezer - Rustim I think his name is?  Some of their own supporters beat him up at a Christmas 'bash' a couple of years back. Bash in more ways than one as it turned out.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#72)

They even have a Jewish councillor. Totally shocking. She must have real issues though, it's obvious that they have neo-nazis amongst them.

Re: The credit crunch and the BNP (#71)

Well done, AD Williams for staying the course. I would have shaken my head and walked away ages ago.

In this age of social engineering, divide and rule is being increasingly used.

In my view, that's the reason for mass immigration, pandering to minorities, feminists promoted to positions of power, etc.

Naturally, survival instincts of hardworking, patriotic British people who see their country turned into a cesspit of crime and debauchery are going to try and find a way to deal with it - and for increasing numbers, that means the BNP. Not me as yet.

But it's New labour's fault. They have created or at least greatly exacerbated the present intolerance and unfairness in society.

You might remember one of my sayings: there is no equality, there is only a hierarchy of ideologies.

The normal law-abiding, taxpaying British people are being pushed right down the ladder of influence and respect.

What do you expect them to do when Labour has treated them with disdain and things only get worse? 

I'm afraid Labour has now given up on almost all the important things like justice, morality and fairness that it once stood for. Its raison d'etre was to protect the ordinary working people, now the leadership doesn't even care about its core supporters.