Question: why are women more conservative than men?

The UK is the only country in the west where women vote more conservatively than men. In the US, Italy, Spain, France, Canada etc. women always swing elections for social democratic or liberal parties.

But in the UK, women always swing elections for conservative parties. Can anyone shed any light on this?



Display: Sort:

Re: Conservative Women. (#1)

What an utterly fascinating question....

Could it be that the Tories perhaps represent more of the traditional familial-side values that simply appeal to British Women?

I don't mean anything as silly as "Kinder, Kuche, Kirche" obviously, but perhaps there is something more...

Reassuring about the Conservatives that appeals to British Women? Or is it perhaps the way in which, perhaps, women are more traditionally minded still in the UK in general? A majority aren't still high-powered buisnesswomen and thus, simply don't have the same will or wish to have the "equality" afforded to them via Labour?

I'm personally not entirely sure, but I strongly suspect a lot of these Conservative Voting women will be mothers. Mothers who will want decent upbringing and discipline for their children outside of their steely gaze, as well as safer streets in general so their kids are safe.

There's also the distinct possibility that they vote Tory simply because they're the only party so far to have had a female leader, just like some Floridia women were swinging in behind Palin simply because she was a female candidate.

Re: Conservative Women. (#3)

My own feeling is that women are more disturbed by change. They are less likely to want to leave their "comfort zone". Labour politicians are always banging on about change and I do not think it scores any points with women.

Re: Conservative Women. (#4)

If this were the case then how come in other countries it would seem to be the other way round? Or do you think this is a purely British phenomenon?

Re: Conservative Women. (#6)

I don't know to be honest.

All I know is that many women - particularly older women (40+) do not like things to change. They seem to prefer stability and predictability.

Just my 2p worth....

Re: Conservative Women. (#5)

That's another possibility, which is what I put under "Traditionally minded". Not stuck-in-the-mud, but more in the mood for gradual change as is necessary for any society.

Keeping still is never an option, but the large-scale changes to a system that already works tends to be a bit bewildering for anybody, let alone women.

Re: Why are women more conservative than men? (#2)

Interesting. How do they know this, is it from polling? My guess would be that it's not that women are more conservative, but that potential Labour voting women are maybe less likely to vote. I have no evidence to back this up, but I could well imagine that in many areas the turnout amongst working class women would be very low.

Re: Why are women more conservative than men? (#7)

That's completely true.

Re: Question: (#8)

I think you have to be careful before really trusting the sort of surveys that this sort of thing tends to be based on as fact; I've seen several sets of figures for different elections in the U.K on this subject that have shown different patterns. Though as the consistent feature is that there is no gender gap of the sort seen in the United States, asking why things are different in Britain is still a valid question. The obvious answer is that class has much more of an influence on voting habits in Britain than in America (to risk understatement actually), but there's probably more to it than that. French voting patterns are not as class-polarised as British ones, and yet (if we believe the surveys) the gender gap in second round of the last Presidential election there was tiny (not true of the first round, interestingly enough; Royal appears to have polled noticably better with women than men in the first round, but not the second. Interestingly, Le Pen certainly did a lot better with men than women and it's very likely that that minority of Le Pen's vote that voted for Royal in the second round was heavily male. And were probably voting for the Commies until the mid '80's).

Re: why are women more conservative than men (#9)

Your favourite Fact Nazi would like to point out that for one thing it isn't true that "in the UK, women always swing elections for conservative parties".

According to IPSOS Mori in the 2005 General Election men voted 34% Con, 34% Lab, 22% LD whilst women voted 32% Con, 38% Lab, 23% LD. Which would rather suggest that women swung the election for Labour.
(See http://www.ipsos-mori.com/content/polls-05/who-voted-which-way-in-detail.ashx)

Indeed from what I could see of research on the subject it would appear that 'New' Labour has always enjoyed greater support from women. Or at least until recently. But then again maybe not. It's the sort of thing pollsters have deep and serious debates about.