Is Gordon Brown losing his sight?

This is from an article in the Daily Mail, where Allison Pearson follows the PM around:

Here's the pertinent bit:

"As the Prime Minister moves along the line of silver-haired Britons, shaking hands and asking if the traffic was bad, I also notice how he finds it impossible to meet people's eye, always looking over their shoulder. Is it shyness?

Damian McBride, Brown's media man until the recent reshuffle, whispers: 'His sight isn't very good.'

McBride tells me about one occasion when the PM was about to meet a line-up of war veterans and his aides noticed that former minister John Reid was in the same queue. Dr Reid had to be moved out of the way because Gordon 'would have confused him with a veteran'.

So is his remaining good eye giving him problems? A senior official, who sat next to the PM in many meetings after 9/11, believes that it is. He told me that all of Brown's memos are in huge print and triple spaced. 'If I want him to reply to an email, I always make sure it's in at least 36 point.' That's almost five times as large as the print size of this article.

Brown's own handwriting is also said to be getting larger. At a conference back in the spring, the Prime Minister took a wrong turn off the stage and failed to find the exit. The incident was reported as comedy, not something far sadder.

.......When I mention his sight to Brown, he makes light of it and avoids direct answers. I ask how much vision he has in the good eye and he chuckles: 'Enough. Enough!' But he admits that, because of the damage done by operations in adolescence, he has had to have a cataract removed."


I must admit that the first thing I did when I read the above was open Word and test out 36 point - and it's big.

The rest of the article is interesting too - a very decent sympathetic interview of Gordon Brown.



Display: Sort:

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#1)

You know, after reading it I think it's entirely possible Brown is losing his sight. He very well could end up as being our first blind PM. I honestly wonder if he's secretly taking braille lessons for that inevitability of sight-loss.

The whole interview is very good, but then I remember that Campbell and Mandleson are back and I feel echos of the "1997 Tribute band" that Polly wrote about in the Guardian recently. I find the timing a little odd, and a little too late in the day. If this had been before Cameron's own "TV Breakfast" or when Mandie and Campbell weren't lurking somewhere in the woodwork I'd find it a very good article...

As it stands... I just don't know.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#2)

On politicalbetting.com it is suggested this might be a gracious way out for the Prime Minister. If it is true he is losing his sight then I don't think he would quit over it.

Everything we know about Gordon says he will battle through personal problems. He will not quit. His future might be "books on tape" but as David Blukett proved you can be a competent minister and blind. Perhaps it might event temper his tendency to micro-manage since it would be harder for him take over the small issues from his ministers (such as St Helena's airport) and get him to concentrate on the big picture.


What would be worse for him, as it would be for any parent, would not be able to see his boys grow up. That means more than any job. I  hope this isn't true and my best wishes go out to him and his family if it is.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#3)

If, as I suspect, it's just part of a damaged retina near to his optic nerve there are now surgical proceedures and electronic chips which can stabilize and even improve his eyesight. It's just a bit of a shame they're still locked away in clinical trials.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#4)

I read about this rumour a while ago, when it was linked with the idea that he could be forced to quit 'for health reasons'.

I don't think he will quit over it nor do I think he should. I hope there is an operation he can have to help him though as I've read a few things noticing that he stumbles over words more lately and if you put the two together it does make sense why in PMQs when he reads out a quote he often stumbles and can't look up when speaking - if he's having trouble reading the words.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#5)

We've had a blind Home Secretary, why not a blind PM?

A while ago a friend of mine said jokingly that he hoped he didn't have to hear GB's story about his eye getting hurt while playing rugby again, as it seemed to feature in lots of his stump speeches last year.  This puts all those references in a different context.  The threat of going blind isn't in the past for Gordon Brown.  It's not his 'back story'- it's his story now, which is always on his mind and affecting the way he lives his life.  Interesting.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#6)

Personally, from the Mail interview I don't think Brown's come to terms with either his diminishing eyesight, or the death of his daughter, Jennifer, back in 2002 and it's effecting him moreso in his job as PM and this is why we've really started to notice his flaws as a person.

He's "Damaged goods" as folks have said before, but on a larger scale than something as personal and as long-back as his rugby accident. The fact that he's still in government shows one of two things.

The guy is made of stronger stuff than any of us, friend or foe would've thought..

OR:

Because he refuses to come to terms with his own limitations and personal demons he's throwing himself at his work as hard as he can and others around him [as the Treasury sickness figures showed during his tenure at the Treasury, which slumped after Darling took over] are being effected by it.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#7)

I think he's made of much stronger stuff than the rest of us! You don't get to become PM if you haven't got grit/determination.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#8)

I'm impressed it took AngryVoter a whole 24 hours to try and work out a way to attack someone over losing a child and going blind!  Clearly a sign of personal growth.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#12)

No, that's one of two simple possibilities a man can go when he goes through trauma like that.

God knows I went through something similar, as did my mother and several friends over the years from various problems. It's one of the reactions to grief and it can go both ways, as snowflake5 says it's probably that the man's made of sterner stuff than we all give him credit for.

As I said it's one of two ways, not a personal attack of any kind thank you RedRooster

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#9)

I think this is a rather  distasteful  post. If Gordon Brown is losing his sight he deserves  our sympathy, not lurid speculation of this   kind.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#10)

I have to agree. We are in the middle of a financial crisis, and Gordon Brown is now sinking his teeth into finding solutions to the current crisis, with hints that he will impose better regulations on the City, and other social-democratic policies. I really don't think we should speculate over Brown's health.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#11)

I disagree. If he's losing his sight then it's perfectly acceptable for us to sympathise. It's also valid to admire him, because in the same situation I sure as hell wouldn't be thinking of the country like he is. Bravo Gordon I say - true courage personified.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#13)

Personal sympathy for Gordon should not obscure the fact that we need a PM who is in full possession of his faculties. If he can't read his briefing papers he cannot do his job properly. Though at least this forces him to delegate more - one reason the latest crisis was handled better is that he left it more to the professionals (King, Kingman, Turner and Myners)

Given his lack of management skills and his obsession with personally reading briefs this problem, if true, should be terminal.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#15)

Could you stoop any lower NB? It's perfectly possible for the blind to function as well as the sighted provided that they have the necessary support.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#16)

It would be very nice if this were true, and I wish it were, but alas it just isn't. With the exception of playing the piano, I cannot think of a single human activity where being blind is not a very serious disadvantage. The rate at which one can take in information is reduced by at least 2 orders or magnitude, and certain types of information simple become inaccessible.

If you can't read body language you simply can't do an effective job chairing a major decision-making body. If you can't read the normal volume of briefing papers you will be hopelessly under-briefed compared to your colleagues.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#17)

I think NB must stand for Not Brown.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#14)

this is very sad. i hope he is ok, i hope he manages to keep his limited sight, but if he loses it i have complete confidence in him carrying on with the job.  This last week has been dramatic, Brown is reasserted as a world statesman, mr cameron looks small, very very small.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#18)








 




Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#19)

Thought this troll was banned.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#20)

So did I.

I mean, I'm all for change, and all for a conservative govt [obv] but this is just... well. Insulting really.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#23)

These logos are a great way of inspiring people about a Conservative change. A plan for change is what we need (you agree), so why not spell it out in big, bold colourful writing?

Okay it is maybe a bit over the top but no one here is going to read blocks of text on Tory polocies. Don't you agree?

Eyes catch colour, like for instance a bright poster. Then that could inspire someone to read what the pictures mean and eventually see what we mean.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#24)

Yes. We love bright shiny things, because we all happen to be 5. Quite frankly, it insults intelligent conservatives who want to debate on policy. Contrary to what you may believe, us socialists genuinally believe that our ideology works, and that conservatism doesn't. You have to convince us otherwise. I am always open to new arguments, and many of my intellectual inspirations come from the right. Please don't insult my intelligence by suggesting that I'm going to defect to the Tories because of a poster.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#26)

Debating policies is great but there not worth debating if they are not the right polocies. We believe that the Conservatie's have good polocies so why not show them off and get them out there in big writing.

Maybe because Gordon and Dave have been at a trouse recently got me bored but now there's been a Conservative attack which will get us debating again.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#21)

Who would have thought that the Tories could spend £250,000 on their new website and still let people hotlink images?

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#22)

Who'd have thought that the Tories would adopt a luminous scribble as their party logo? Too many lines of coke clouding judgement at Tory HQ, methinks.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#25)

so why not spell it out in big, bold colourful writing?

indeed Matrix, like a child with a new set of crayons...

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#27)

Yes indeed. Exactly what you said. We need to rub out everything Labour has done and then artistically curve Brittian with our views for the future. We will draw up the best plans for the future on the economy, defence, housing, prisons etc etc.

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#28)

*Britian

Re: Is Gordon Brown losing his sight? (#29)

*Britain even!!!