Cameron's Hypocrisy on Northern Rock

Nick Robinson has noted in his blog how quickly David Cameron has backed away from blaming Gordon Brown for the problems at Northern Rock.


Nick writes:-

Just to remind you, the Conservative leader wrote in the Sunday Telegraph that, "though the current crisis may have had its trigger in the US, over the past decade, the gun has been loaded at home."

Today, though he repeats his criticism of economic growth "built on a mountain of debt", there is not the slightest hint of a direct connection between the government's economic policies and Northern Rock's problems. No wonder.

---

But he could have gone much further.

Only a few weeks ago, he was welcoming the publication of John Redwood's policy task group report on deregulation. And what does this have to say about mortgage regulation? The following:-

"Mortgage Regulation. We see no need to continue to regulate the provision of mortgage finance, as it is the lending institutions rather than the client taking the risk."

David Cameron's policy group want to see just the kind of unregulated mortgage policy in this country that has led to the 'sub prime' collapse in the United States. And then he wants to try to blame the Government for the current problem with Northern Rock?



Display: Sort:

Re: Cameron's Hypocrisy on Northern Rock (#1)

George Osborne made himself look like a complete idiot tonight on Channel 4 News. He was basically criticising the government's attitude to debt but then going on to say that if the Tories were to get back into power, they wouldn't do anything different.

Let's remember, it was the Thatcher government which first lifted the restrictions on credit so if the Tories don't like the current situation they can blame themselves.

But of course, as Redwood stated in the report, the Tories ideally would prefer even less regulation on credit and mortgages, so once again, this is pure political opportunism from Cameron.

Re: Cameron's Hypocrisy on Northern Rock (#2)

To be fair I do'nt blame them for trying to make political capital out of it, if things were reversed does one really think that Gordon Brown and Alastair Darling as Shadow Leader and Shadow Chancellor would be clapping on the sidelines saying how well the Government had done.  It's just the nature of politics.

One can argue that Labour was just as guilty of 'political opportunism' in the 90s when we came out of the ERM.  It's often airbrushed out of history that Brown and much of the political establishment fully supported the UK's entry into the ERM.  Yet since then the blame has been fully pinned onto the Tories.

We might not like what Cameron and Osborne are trying to do, but can we really say hand on heart that Labour would not do the same in opposition?  All political parties indulge in opportunism day in day out, frankly it's how they are successful. 

Re: Cameron's Hypocrisy on Northern Rock (#3)

Of course the Tories are entitled to try and gain some votes out of this, but equally, we in Labour are entitled to accuse them of opportunism and stirring up trouble, so at the end of the day we just cancel each other out.

Re: Cameron's Hypocrisy on Northern Rock (#4)

A good piece on this subject in today's Independent by Dominic Lawson

'Its no wonder the Tories blame Brown':
http://comment.independent.co.uk/columnists_a_l/dominic_lawson/article2974572.ece