Fabian leadership hustings: Read the full transcript

The full transcript of last night’s Fabian hustings event, with Gordon Brown, John McDonnell and Michael Meacher, can now be read on the Fabian website.

Whether you attended last night, saw or heard the debate on the TV or radio,  or have read the transcript, let us know what you thought?


The full transcript of last night’s Fabian hustings event, with Gordon Brown, John McDonnell and Michael Meacher, can now be read on the new Fabian website, at the link below.

http://fabians.org.uk/events/hustings-07-leaders/speech


We were very keen to ensure that there was a chance to debate the major issues facing the party and the government.  The Fabian Society would like to thank the Institute of Education for hosting the event at short notice and so well. Many thanks to our members, and those of our partners - Labour Students, Progress and the Young Fabians – for coming along to take part and make the event a success.

With around 100 audience questions submitted, we could cover only a small number in an hour and a half. You might be interested to know that the most popular theme of the questions submitted – by some distance – was inequality, life chances and extending opportunity, with several questions on how Labour could narrow the gaps in our society and on how the 2020 target to meet child poverty could be met.

As the foreign policy discussion and floor contributions demonstrated, members were also keen to discuss a wide range of important international questions – Israel and Palestine; Iraq; Iran; Darfur and humanitarian intervention; global poverty and development, and Europe. This will be an important focus for the Fabian Society in the build-up to January’s New Year Conference on international issues.

Questions on challenges of rebuilding Labour’s membership and of appealing beyond Labour’s core support to win the next election were also a popular theme: we hope that this will also be an important issue for the Deputy Leadership debate which the Fabian Society and Progress hold this Wednesday night.







Display: Sort:

Re: Fabian leadership debate (#1)

I watched the debate on Sky. As to be expected, Gordon Brown was head and shoulders above the other two. Indeed GB looked bored when the other two participants spoke and was clearly preparing for his next contribution. I thought John McDonnell and Michael Meacher were abysmal and they certainly do not live in the same world as me. GB was right to say that the policies put forward by both were firmly rejected in the 80's and the country could not afford them. Given that the debate was televised it was disgraceful that John McDonnell was not wearing a tie. I am amused that Mr Meacher and Mr McDonnell aspire to be PM (how arrogant can you get) and sincerely hope that neither gets the required support to challenge GB. Yes, I would have liked a contest but not from these two MPs. In the unlikely event that either would win an election, I would join the mass exodus (business and the City) and depart the country.

Re: Fabian leadership debate (#2)

Is this a joke? Not wearing a tie? Taking your lead from "business and the City"? McDonnell and Meacher are arrogant (possibly need a dictionary) but Gordon Brown is the one looking bored while they speak? This must be an attempt at a humorous parady of a Blairite, I presume.

Re: Fabian leadership debate (#3)

What a horrid little comment! So it's arrogant to contest an election now, is it? Whereas looking bored by others' contriubtions isn't arrogant at all?! Blair regularly appears without a tie on telly. Was this post a joke?

Re: Fabian leadership debate (#5)

True liz, but there's really no chance of them winning! Gordon was head and shoulders above the other two - he looked more like a Prime Minister and he spoke confidently and his policies were sound. Well, we won't see Meacher again and McDonnell made it plainly obvious why he is completely unsuitable to the vast majority of the population.

Re: Fabian leadership hustings: (#4)

Aside from the rather bizarre comment previously - I'd like to say thanks to all involved for arranging the debate and ensuring that all potential candidates were able to contribute. I hope it won't be the last proper hustings we see in the leadership contest.

Re: Fabian leadership hustings: (#6)

Don't overreact! There was nothing wrong with liz's comment.

Re: Fabian leadership hustings: (#7)

Well sorry if I did over-react, it just seemed bizarre: why should John McDonnell (or Michael Meacher, for that matter) wanting to stand to be Labour leader be any more 'arrogant' than Gordon Brown wanting to stand? And is it only left-wingers who have to wear ties when they go on the telly? But I don't want to have an argument about it, just wasn't sure how serious it was.