Charles Clarke is wrong about NHS charging.
Whatever the merits of market mechanisms in the NHS, there is a growing suspicion on the part of staff and public that the increasing use of the private sector in the NHS is not actually about improved efficiency through competition but simply about saving money at a time when the government is determined to cut public spending. Mr Clarke's intervention will only heighten this suspicion.
Labour is beginning to get into unnecessary trouble on what should be home territory - it is not hard to imagine how Mr Clarke's comments will be used by our opponents in a bid to suggest that the NHS is no longer safe in Labour's hands.
I would much prefer we focus any future discussions on the suggestions that the NHS should be more distant from politicians - if constructed properly such a proposal could be used as a basis for a fresh start (though equally it could be used to try and lock in wrong policies).
It is not 'brave' of Charles Clarke to raise this issue, it is foolish and potentially very damaging.


