Newsnight and Policy Exchange

According to BBC Newsnight, a Policy Exchange   report into "The Hijacking of British Islam" has questionable evidence.

Policy exchange visited over a 100 mosques, and came back stating that 25 or so were promoting an extreme version of Islam.

However, Newsnight has discovered in 5 out of the 6 mosques it visited which Policy Exchange had pointed out that were selling extremist literature, that the receipts given by Policy Exchange for the literature bought are questionable.

Things like wrong addresses, receipts that aren't the same as the ones in the actual shops and receipts printed on expensive-to-print-on inkjets all featured.

The report itself was a bombshell, and helped put Policy Exchange on the map. Now it is called into question.

It should matter to Labour members, because Policy Exchange is the Conservative's favourite think tank, and has had Cameron to speak very recently. It is almost the research arm of the Conservative Party.

This also calls into question Policy Exchange's other reports, and, of course, with it, Tory policies.

 



Display: Sort:

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#1)

"This also calls into question...Tory policies"

Any particularly ones?

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#8)

Considering the amount of pies Policy Exchange has its neo con fingers, i'd say nearly all of them.

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#2)

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#3)

Iain Dale resigned as a trustee of Policy Exchange 27 Feb 2007 - I wonder if he had an inkling things were going out of control there? Michael Gove resigned the year before, 18 Jan 2006.

Policy Exchange has a £984k income in 2006, up from £568k in 2005. Wonder where that came from? Shame left-wing "Think Tanks" cannot so easily raise that kind of money - with tax reclaimed as the "educational charity" Policy Exchange can!

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#4)

It will be interesting to see how much of Dean Godson's background comes out of all this.
His brother Roy is a leading expert on psychological warfare who was implicated in the Iran-Contra Affair. He has also had political links in Britain that raise questions for the Labour Party as well as the Tories.
Roy's book Dirty Trick or Trump Cards includes a discussion of the role of forgery in 'political warfare.'
It's reasonable to ask whether the 'political warfare' that Dean has advocated in his newspaper columns involves the same methods.
Spinwatch: The Godson Approach to Political Warfare

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#5)

The real question here is...

What does David Cameron think of this policy exchange business?

Does he disapprove Policy Exchange's tactics or is he happy to continue to let an organisation that falsifies it's research keep it's close ties to the Conservative party? Either way, David Cameron has some questions to answer.

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#6)

Good question.  What I'd like to know as well is what Gordo thinks of the Smith Institute and Opinion Leader research. 

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#7)

Have either of them falsified research in such a way that it could cause signifigant racial tensions, or anything of similar magnitude that could threaten the wellbeing of this country's citizens?

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#9)

I don't know.  I think we should be told though...

On a serious note, I think you underestimate the power of people like Policy Exchange.  Do really think we're going to have blood in the streets because a think-tank said something?  You guys are sounding pretty rattled at the moment...

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#10)

There wasn't blood on the steets due to the David Abrahams business either, but that didn't stop the Tories relentlessly using that story to it's advantage.

In terms of the potential harm each affair could have done to the nation, what policy exchange have done is far worse.

Not only that, they did it deliberately and intentionally and have since stood by it. Policy exchange's behavour is utterly morally abhorrent and since the Tories have said very little on the subject, we can only assume that the Tories approve of such abhorrent behavoir.

Re: Newsnight and Policy Exchange (#11)

Deliberately and intentionally? Do you have the evidence to back that up or do you just want LabourHome sued?