Why are you Labour?

Now that it’s occasionally forgivable to take an idea from those freedom-loving, government fearing, free-market evangelicals at the Conservative Party – I’ve decided to put a question to you that I’ve stumbled across on ConservativeHome.

They’ve asked PPC’s why they are Conservatives. The resulting collection of platitudes, misdirection and cynical, unreasoned box-ticking can be found here:

Alongside, to be fair, about four good answers.

It prompts a predictable question – why are you Labour?

A lot of people support their party because their parents encouraged them to, or, at the very least, gave them an interest in politics. This is not my experience - I grew up in Ireland where people either come from a political family or they grow up fiercely cynical of all politicians and the band of risible apologists that follow them around (we were the latter). 

I joined the Labour Party this year because I’m certain that this group is the one most capable, and most likely, to lead to an improving society. I’m left leaning because I see us as more likely to tackle a problem with a practical, reasoned, fair and open-minded approach.

I’m Labour because we don’t care how a family is made up as long as the people within it are safe, stable, contributing to society and get a fair crack of the whip. We don’t see humanity or the value of human life as meaningless beyond Dover so we increase foreign aid.

Labour understands we need a place at the centre table in a strong Europe now that the world’s problems are getting pretty dire - national sovereignty to decide the size of jelly beans will mean little when we’re under 10 foot (or 3 1/3 yards) of water.

I understand that the free market is free but not that it can do whatever it likes – come what may. Otherwise, we’d have called it the reckless abandon market. Yes - the market is quick to react to opportunities but it is often a little too slow to react to problems.

I believe lower taxes are an objective – not a philosophy. There’s no validity in the false economy of underfunding a hospital or school now, if we have to pay through the nose for its resulting failures later.

I also believe in personal responsibility but we can’t blithely stand back from personal irresponsibility. If someone wants to drive a 4x4 in Chelsea – fine, but with that comes congestion, unnecessary pollution, increased petrol consumption and more pedestrian fatalities, all with a greater costs to the rest of us – Urban 4x4 owners should pay their share of that.

The final reason I’m Labour though – is this Government. It’s had some dreadful errors and has had some woeful decisions (including this wretched detention proposal) but, when all the good is added up and the bad subtracted, it’s a very positive balance sheet.

So why are you Labour?


Display: Sort:

Re: Why are you Labour? (#1)

I believe in social-democracy, progressive values, social justice, liberal social policies, freedom, democracy, equality, fairness, secularism, patriotism rather than nationalism, meritocracy rather than aristocracy, lifting up the poor and disadvantaged whilst not knocking down the rich, and a tolerant, open society.

Labour are the closest any party gets to all of these things.

Re: Why are you Labour? (#12)

I'd go along with that, while adding internationalist rather than nationalist, and wealth without giving anything back is wrong.

Re: Why are you Labour? (#13)

Couldn't really sum it up better. Think I have been political since Thatcher cut my school milk! Like others, grew up in the early 80s at a school in poor repair and ill equipped to do the job - and in a prosperous part of the South too. Saw what was happening in the cities and in the mining areas on tv, but didn't join till OMOV and the rise of Blair/Brown. Don't really have a life (or a job) outside of politics now and wonder what I'm going to do if things carry on the way they are going...

Re: Why are you Labour? (#2)


Because I grew up in the 80s and saw the damage that Thatcherism wrought upon the people, industries and communities of this country.  I saw great histories sold off to the highest bidder.  Because I believe in values, not just market prices; because I believe in the common ownership of the means of production, distribution  and exchange - that that is the best way to secure for all workers - by hand and by brain - the full fruits of their industry.  Because I'm tribally attached to the labour movement, its history and its present: the trade union movement and the political organisation of labour.  Because I hate the tories with all my stomach.

Because I believe in international solidarity and justice; because I believe in nothing short of turning the world upside down.

Re: Why are you Labour? (#3)

Ditto to both above comments. Why Labour? If i don't know by now, I'll never know!

Re: Why are you Labour? (#4)

I believe in fairness and equality, both necessary for freedom. I believe we should live in a diverse, tolerant society, and one which welcomes others when they join it. I believe in working closely with other states to solve global challenges. I believe in a managed market economy where government can act to ensure everyone benefits. I am opposed to elitism, suspicion and distrustfulness and tradition just for the sake of it. I believe people are generally pretty good and think it is within our capacity to improve the lives of everyone.


I support the party for one negative reason. Given the dominance of two parties in the UK, it wouldn't be sensible, if we want left-of-centre policies, to vote for another social democratic party, even if it stood more for what we wanted. 

Re: Why are you Labour? (#5)

The voices told me to be.

Re: Why are you Labour? (#6)

I am Labour because ours is the only Party based on fundamental morality, that all are equal and that we are all diminshed when one of our fellow humans suffers. This is the vision that I wish the PM would communicate. It's not new and its not dreamt up by marketeers, but it is a timeless message about who we are.

Re: Why are you Labour? (#7)

When Labour returns i will be able to answer, right now I see no difference what so ever between the parties at all.

Re: Why are you Labour? (#8)

Ahh..The return of the old flat cap and wippits.......

Re: Why are you Labour? (#9)

I believe in a socially tempered market system - Markets have proved the most effective means of generating wealth (& jobs) and it is this creation of wealth that allows a progressive social agenda to be pursued. Generally people are only interested in equality, social justice, international aid and various ideas if they feel financially comfortable and today that usually means a house, car etc

I believe in equality of opportunity but I think for that to be achieved you need taxation and subsequent investment in public services that help to level the playingfield: education, health, flexible working, childcare, training etc

Re: Why are you Labour? (#10)

I'm "Labour" but wonder why, when we now have Tebbitite Peter 'Hammer to the Sick' Hain about to prey on the weak and vulnerable.

Re: Why are you Labour? (#11)

I'm a product of the 1980s- saw the evil consequences of the free market horror that was Thatcherism. The danger for Labour today is that younger folk do not know the horror of those years and how the wealthy exploited ordinary people. I teach History and any student of history will tell you that the Tories have shafted ordinary people at every given opportunity throughout the ages, voting against every piece of progressive legislation of the past century, including the NHS and the minimum wage. What a despicable shower- all of these new Cameroons are the same old nasty lot lurking underneath. Let's just hope people don't fall for the Toff's con-trick. Whatever you say about Labour, they are the most ordinary of any of the three parties- Dave is desperate to convince us that the Toffs have changed- they never will, the bloodsport loving aristos!!