Pulling the Teeth of the Dentist Story

Much of today's radio and television news has been dominated by the latest dental care horror story. But the story is not all it is cracked up to be - isn't it time Labour as a party and a Government got better at responding to this kind of story?


The story is based on a survey - better called a campaign - called Dental Watch, carried out by local Patient Public Involvement (PPIs) Forums and coordinated by the Commission for Patient and Public Involvement for Health. You can read their press release about the survey or access the full details here.

Some quick points that have been lost in the press coverage.

This is NOT a statistical survey. The forms have been circulated through the local PPIs, so the responses are largely from a self-selecting group. It is entirely likely that those replying are more likely to be those who have a complaint about at least some aspect of their dental care.

This is equally true of the survey of dentists, which covers 750 responses out of more than 20,000 dentists nationally.

The BBC website report is carefully worded in how it refers to the survey; not so, however, the headlines on Radio 5live which said that '20% of people in Britain have gone without dental treatment because of the cost'. This is NOT a valid interpretation of this survey, and we should not let them get away with it.

Of course a survey of this kind highlights and gives a voice to legitimate concerns and issues. But it is not a scientific and representative survey and cannot claim to give an accurate picture of public opinion and experiences. Not only is there no representative sample involved, but also it would appear no mechanism for checking and verifying some of the more lurid individual examples quoted.

There is a legitimate debate to be had about the state of oral health and dentistry. I believe that the changes Labour has made are broadly working and are increasing access to dentistry - which has never been anything like a universal service. (And if anyone thinks that the NHS charges are unreasonably high they should scroll to the bottom of the BBC story to see the comparison with typical private charges).


PS. Apologies for the bad pun in the headline ....



Display: Sort:

Re: Pulling the Teeth of the Dentist Story (#1)

So my grandson who was seen on TV and in the media, who is now eight years old has never seen a dentist in his life, I tried my best to get him onto a private list sadly they stated he had to be seen first by the NHS get any treatment and then and only then he would be taken on as a private patient.

last year he went seriously ill and I took him to the hospital, he was so ill doctors could not understand until they asked a dental surgeon to take a look, in an hour he had fourteen teeth removed . Now we are told his second teeth are infected and will need removing my god he is eight years old.

I have letters from me to MP's I have letters to the Welsh Assembly asking begging for a dentist being told rubbish dentist are available, I have letters emails from the local health authority saying we have no NHS dentist Blair contacted me saying you will have a dentist this week, I have a letter from the local Health Authority saying no you will not. I have a folder with people writing to me saying we are in the same boat.


My wife and I have not seen an NHS dentist for ten years since Labour took over, and a long TV interview I was again told by Labour OK you will now have a dentist we will contact your MP, but nothing came of that.


This is not a survey this is life in my area I know of about twenty other kids without a dentist.


Last year my wife suffering severe toothache, I held her down took a pliers and took her tooth out. My young grandson I've had to fill two of his teeth with a special mixture you can buy for temporary fillings This is life.

this is real life under labour not the Tories but labour.