Labour Needs A Culture Change

The party cannot stand divided against itself. Only our opponents gain from the dismaying spectacle of a Labour Party dominated by briefing, counter-briefing and darkly looking in on itself.

It may be that Tony Blair is forced out even before the 12 month period now conceded. If he is then he will have been finally pushed by no else but Labour MPs. History will conclude that it was not the Conservatives, on the sidelines lapping up our discontent, nor public revolt of the sort over the poll tax that so damaged Thatcher, that ended the Blair era, but rather his own party,stabbing him in the front, that dealt the terminal blow.

Any apparently worthy short-term gains that have pushed former loyalists to rebellion, will surely be outweighed by the spectre that will come to haunt the party. For the lesson of the strange death of the Conservative Party is best learnt in what happened following Thatcher's ousting; a party divided internally within and externally without, an electorate utterly put off by a party lacking the ability to heal its own divisions let alone those within the country, and the revitalisation of a newly pragmatic opposition more readily able to present its case to form a government.

I am no ardent supporter of the Prime Minister's most controversial policies; i marched against the Iraq War and have opposed the government for instance on student finance reform, and on the more draconian aspects of the anti-terorist legislation. Thus, my backing for the Prime Minister's stance in this case is more pragmatic than ideological, as well as owing something to my respect for his democratic mandate and the progressive changes he has enabled.

However, whenever Blair may depart, the necessary challenges we must face if we are to move forward will remain the same. Amidst the drama of the past few days and the drama no doubt yet to come, the more nuanced Labour members would do well to keep one eye on the long game.

Individuals from various sides of the party have entered the debate in recent weeks but we would be wrong to see panaceas as lying in either the adoption of a Blairite ten year plan, boxing a future leader in, nor in the naive assumption that we must place all our hopes in a smooth transition to Gordon Brown with little debate prior to this.

 A debate now is necessary, but we should avoid debating the future solely through the prisms of personality and policy, important as they are, and take in issues such as party organisation and the policy process itself.

Charles Clarke's recent analysis of the party's problems in a New Statesman piece (http://www.newstatesman.com/200609040029) and yesterday in a speech (http://www.guardian.co.uk/guardianpolitics/story/0,,1865840,00.html) was well worth hearing. Clarke rightly identified the reform process itself as a serious fault-line for the party. He usefully argues for ' the right structures, the right culture,an approach of partnership with employees and stakeholders, and a commitment to engage fully'.

It is a shame he did not apparently raise such points during the policy debacles of top-up fees and trust schools. There was little or no debate or discussion around these policies before they were loosed on the party. Hence the inevitably large rebellions on these issues, born as much out of shock as out of ideology. The government forced itself into a situation of rather embarassing concessions and rightly appeared weakened to the media and public.

For too long the myth was allowed to develop that 'strong' policy making consisted of the presentation of fait accomplis to the party. On the contrary, a truly strong and confident government should be willing to engage itself in debate and discussion before policy presentation, rather than pulling out compromise deals at the last minute. Relatively few Labour MPs believe in rebellion for rebellions sake and too many have been unecessarily alienated by the governments approach. The same alienation has occured on a micro-level for grassroots activists. Honest members looking for honest debate have been put off by overly managed policy forums and documents following consultation which pay scant regard to reasonable concerns.

We must hope Gordon Brown, if leader, adopts a more consesual approach though his preference for simple words in favour of Trident rather than the presentation of intellectual arguments does not bode well.

Beyond the policy process we must also rebuild our party from the bottom upwards. Too little has been said on the catastrophe of a haemoragging of half of our members since 1997. We would do well to remember the significant contribution that an ever smaller, weaker and demoralised activist base made to the Conservative collapse, rather than simple defeat, in 1997. One obvious proposal would be to remodel the party's chair as an elected position, immediately creating new lines of accountability.

At a time when personal tensions are bubbling over, we could do worse than remember the underlying structural issues that we must wrangle with if we are to ensure that Labour's achievements to date are the firm foundations of the good society, rather than the footnotes of a divisive Conservative future.


Display: Sort:

Re: Labour Needs A Culture Change (#1)

As a Labour Party activist I am fully agree with you, what ever you wrote regarding Party and regarding this country. We need to be stay united and finish this leadership drama as soon as possible. Ground reality is we, Labour Party going down and we need to bring our Party graph up before next national elections. That's only possible through bring changes in the Labour policies and changes in the Labour Party it self. That is directly in benefical of the Party as well as in benefical to the United Kingdom.

Re: Labour Needs A Culture Change (#2)

求佛 流行音乐跟踪日志 MP3选购指南 手机选购指南 jiejie85的手机世界 beibei的共享空间 姐姐游戏世界 求佛 老公老公我爱你 一万个理由 香水有毒 老婆老婆我爱你 不怕不怕 寂寞沙洲冷 吉祥三宝 不要再来伤害我 披着羊皮的狼 隐形的翅膀 大城小爱 桃花朵朵开 神话 曹操 那一夜 狼爱上羊 你是我的玫瑰花 死了都要爱 上海滩 生日礼物 三只小熊 发如雪 夜曲 不得不爱 爱如空气 笔记 不想长大 反转地球 飞舞 宁夏 眉飞色舞 两只小蜜蜂 QQ爱 爸爸妈妈 香飘飘 香水百合 我不后悔 约定 童话 舞娘 嘻唰唰 两只蝴蝶 飞行部落 累斗累 认真的雪 报答 秋天不回来 寻找李慧珍 瞬间倾心恒久钟情 求佛铃声 老公老公我爱你铃声 一万个理由铃声 香水有毒铃声 老婆老婆我爱你铃声 不怕不怕铃声 寂寞沙洲冷铃声 吉祥三宝铃声 不要再来伤害我铃声 披着羊皮的狼铃声 隐形的翅膀铃声 大城小爱铃声 桃花朵朵开铃声 神话铃声 曹操铃声 那一夜铃声 狼爱上羊铃声 你是我的玫瑰花铃声 死了都要爱铃声 上海滩铃声 生日礼物铃声 三只小熊铃声 发如雪铃声 夜曲铃声 不得不爱铃声 爱如空气铃声 笔记铃声 不想长大铃声 反转地球铃声 飞舞铃声 宁夏铃声 眉飞色舞铃声 两只小蜜蜂铃声 QQ爱铃声 爸爸妈妈铃声 香飘飘铃声 香水百合铃声 我不后悔铃声 约定铃声 童话铃声 舞娘铃声 嘻唰唰铃声 两只蝴蝶铃声 飞行部落铃声 累斗累铃声 认真的雪铃声 报答铃声 秋天不回来铃声 寻找李慧珍铃声 瞬间倾心恒久钟情铃声 求佛铃声下载 老公老公我爱你铃声下载 一万个理由铃声下载 香水有毒铃声下载 老婆老婆我爱你铃声下载 不怕不怕铃声下载 寂寞沙洲冷铃声下载 吉祥三宝铃声下载 不要再来伤害我铃声下载 披着羊皮的狼铃声下载 隐形的翅膀铃声下载 大城小爱铃声下载 桃花朵朵开铃声下载 神话铃声下载 曹操铃声下载 那一夜铃声下载 狼爱上羊铃声下载 你是我的玫瑰花铃声下载 死了都要爱铃声下载 上海滩铃声下载 生日礼物铃声下载 三只小熊铃声下载 发如雪铃声下载 夜曲铃声下载 不得不爱铃声下载 爱如空气铃声下载 笔记铃声下载 不想长大铃声下载 反转地球铃声下载 飞舞铃声下载 宁夏铃声下载 眉飞色舞铃声下载 两只小蜜蜂铃声下载 QQ爱铃声下载 爸爸妈妈铃声下载 香飘飘铃声下载 香水百合铃声下载 我不后悔铃声下载 约定铃声下载 童话铃声下载 舞娘铃声下载 嘻唰唰铃声下载 两只蝴蝶铃声下载 飞行部落铃声下载 累斗累铃声下载 认真的雪铃声下载 报答铃声下载 秋天不回来铃声下载 寻找李慧珍铃声下载 瞬间倾心恒久钟情铃声下载