Will Brown makes us all socialists again?

Collective endeavour (or Socialism) is, to my mind, both a strength and a virtue. The belief in solidarity, that we are always stronger when we unite together, that collaboration can be better than competition is what makes me a socialist.

As Jack Straw points out in this week's New Statesman, the pursuit of equality is at the heart of the Labour movement. Straw argues, rightly in my view, that:

'In an increasingly atomised society, it is all the more imperative that we make our voices heard in arguing for solidarity, for a sense of community and for the democratic socialist way where, by working together, we can be stronger.'

Gordon Brown also believes in the strength and virtue of collective endeavour - locally, nationally and internationally. Can Brown (will Brown) make the term 'socialism' respectable once again? Should he, and perhaps more importnatly, does it matter?


Display: Sort:

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#1)

Interesting. This is something I was thinking about the other day. Is the term irretrievably tainted by statism in the minds of the sort of voters we need voting for us?

My guess would be that, should he become leader, Brown wont use it as one of his main problems (at least at first) will be to head off public worried of a post-Blair return to Old Labour.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#6)

I think that the word 'socialism' has been tainted over the years. The far left helped to destroy respect for the word, whilst Margaret Thatcher crippled it futher in the general population and Kinnock/New Labour purged it from the party.

Socialism nowdays means either communism or very watery and pathetic social democracy.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#7)

I agree. Only a small number of people still believe the word socialism means anything other that what otware said above.

Does it really matter if the word stops being used?

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#2)

Since the French Revolution there has been this idea of a "spectrum of politics" from left to right and that human nature somehow fits on that spectrum - it has obsessed intellectuals for hundreds of years.

As an idea it is a completely flawed. It's followers are intellectually flawed.

It is human nature that has a spectrum not politics.

Some of us were born to live in communes other to be  ruthless entrepeneurs. The rest of us live in a normal distribution between these two extremes.

Politics should give each of us the ability to express our nature not supress it as part of an intellectual effort.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#4)

One thing that disturbs me is the lack of any opportunity to opt out of society, it being a construct imposed on us from birth and defined by people who had no idea what they were creating.

I'm not sure this state of affairs is ultimately sustainable. Aren't we all just little hamsters in a wheel?

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#13)

If a party offered a high and low tax regimes how would you ever lose power?  

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#3)

The problem is that the Blairites have made the language of class very different to use and access- they have essentially made it impossible for a Labour leader to use without him being attacked from within his own party for becoming Michael Foot. Consequently I think that Brown will attempt a further riff on the his already important theme by consistently sounding rightwing and acting leftwing- whether that is a coherent longterm strategy I don't know.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#5)

I hope this thread keeps going. It could turn out to be incredibly interesting.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#8)

I don't think socialism is consistent with continually opening up our public services to private companies in order that they can profit from these services - nor with enthusiastic support for imperialist foreign policy. So I don't see Brown as much of a standard bearer for socialism.

I do think that the Party needs to rediscover socialism though. Politics is in danger of being reduced to an almost apolitical squabble over a tiny bit of "middle ground" as all parties accept that capitalism no longer gives the state scope even for "social democracy in one country."

In these circumstances turn out in elections will not recover as we will be failing to offer an alternative vision which corresponds to the interests of working people.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#9)

I understand the point you're making, but is the term 'socialism' really about specific policies (such as public ownership) or is it more about Socialist 'values' such as equality?

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#10)

Is the term and the definition really the important factor? Surely it's how policy affects people's lives that matters more than the label under which that policy is branded?

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#11)

i agree

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#14)

I agree too, to a certain extent, though I'm a proud socialist.  I think socialism for most in the labour movement is primarily about a way of doing things rather than about a golden-age, imagined future.  It's the journey rather than the destination.  However, it is quite clear that putting profit before people is not a socialist way of doing things, and is not a sight to be seen on the socialist journey.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#16)

No way, unless we brand ourselves as New Socialists. I agree, its not what you call ourselves that matters its how you adapt policies to the world and economic climate we live in today and make them meaningful to the punters out there who, frankly, aren't very politically literate.
We have a lot of educating to do and tossing words like socialism around doesn't help one bit. In fact, let's consign the word to the dustbin; it is completely outmoded.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#12)

It's not raising tax that's the problem it's spending it.

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#15)

Will Brown makes us all socialists again? Not if he keeps saying silly things like this.

"I stand with people like Mrs Thatcher"

"Margaret Thatcher had discipline, leadership, character and conviction"

Re: Will Brown makes us all socialists again? (#17)

Any rush to reclaim the term 'socialism' would probably harm us and provide far too easy an attack for Cameron and the rightwing press on Tony Blairs successor. As long as Gordon lays out active policies to address inequality and promote social mobility, I see no real need to reintroduce the word into the current political vocabulary. I'm sure as the centre gorund becomes more left wing (very slightly) and Labour remains in government the word will begin to be adopted, or seen as more acceptable to the electorate anyway.
There was an interesting article in the Guardian (tuesday 20th) about socialism in action from the bottom upwards, in the form of communitity groups, trade unions and religions working together for each others aims, as opposed to it being imposed from the top down, perhaps this is what a Labour government should aim for.