Is party politics making a mockery of democracy?

Democracy!
People power!
And we've got it!
......right?

A week or 2 ago i saw something on the telly that sparked my interest. It was a muslim extremist telling the world that democracy had failed in Britain and that the bright and glorious future of Britain lay in us throwing down our decadent, liberal and/or christian beliefs and adopting shiite law.
 Of course i gave the man the same sought of respect i'd give any nutter with a well honed one finger salute and switched channel, but it did get me down to thinking, is democracy really working? My answer, no.
 This isn't some plea for different systems of election or to reduce the amount of corporate sensorship in the mainstream press (although i would of course vote for both), its simply a look at what i think is happenning to peoples' views in this country.
 First people seem to feel very very separated from the people in charge of this country. they may have voted for Labour but they don't feel connected to the politicians in any way, in fact its probably the oppossite.
 Second people feel quite powerless over the decisions made in government. People power seems to have become a myth in this country. Union mobilization is given secondary interest by the press (i wonder why?) and if you were to tell people that they had real power over the decisions that affect their lives they'd probably just give you a funny look and mumble 'yeah sure'.
 Worst of all people don't see this as a problem in our 'democracy' or atleast not one that is curable.

 So who do we point the finger at for this current state of affairs?
 I point it directly at the political parties. Although the internet has helped in creating more democratic party systems with sites like this (though one does wonder if this site is censored), political parties still provide something for politicians to hide behind. Politicians use party systems to their own benefit or their enemies downfall, as anybody would, and this turns parties not into somewhere to help and discuss ideas freely with people of relatively similar viewpoints, but into PR centres. Sometimes i even get the feeling that the labour party isn't a democratic institution anymore but rather a PR corporation where we meet to discuss how best to spin. I get this feeling too at times with the lib dems (I classify myself as belonging to both) even though you get greater power within the liberal democrats as a member (cheaper too i think)!

 This as well as the cheap tricks major parties use against one another (ever heard 'Labour can't win here' in your neighbourhood) has caused some people to feel powerless against the machinery of the party, has helped to stagnate Britain's democratic system with low turnout as well as taking power away from people and pushing it into the reckless arms of high politics.

 So what should we do? well thats upto all of us normal party members really but i think some general rules can be applied to get democracy back on its feet.
Number 1. Ordinary people should have the power.
 Power should be taken away from the party leaders and given to the party members.
Number 2. The ends do not justify the means.
 End the cheap tricks and PR and focus our efforts on doing good instead (having all party members join together to fight the BNP would be nice).
Number 3. Punish those who have failed.
 If a labour MP has failed in his constituency to do good then it should not be expected of us to gather round him/her with support. we can't just support our own politicians we have to hold them accountable.
Number 4. Judge people not on their party but on themselves.
Other political parties are not our enemies, they just have different points of view. Sometimes they simply offer different means of achieving the same ends we want and constantly attacking them can at times be counterproductive to our cause.

disagree as and where you see fit and feel free to comment.
John
 


Display: Sort:

Re: Is party politics making a mockery of democrac (#1)

Number 1. Ordinary people should have the power.
 Power should be taken away from the party leaders and given to the party members.

Party members' views are often as alien to the rest of the electorate as the views of political leaders. As politicos, we could all get riled up about a Conservative party that wanted to bring back capital punishment & the birch in schools vs. a Labour Party that wanted to renationalise stuff, but the majority of the population would just sit there thinking "what on earth has this got to do with what I want for the country?"

Number 2. The ends do not justify the means.
 End the cheap tricks and PR and focus our efforts on doing good instead (having all party members join together to fight the BNP would be nice).

In a lot of cases the ends justify the means. Would the people who've benefited from the minimum wage and tax credits give it all back for an end to spin? Do the people around the world who've benefited from a doubling of the UK's international aid budget lay awake at night, wracked with guilt that they are benefiting from Alistair Campbell's spin machine? I don't imagine so.


Number 3. Punish those who have failed.
 If a labour MP has failed in his constituency to do good then it should not be expected of us to gather round him/her with support. we can't just support our own politicians we have to hold them accountable.

Fair enough. But we'd have to make sure we were distinguishing between people who have failed and people who were simply under unjustified attack from the media or opposition. Sometimes people find it hard to tell the difference.

Number 4. Judge people not on their party but on themselves.
Other political parties are not our enemies, they just have different points of view. Sometimes they simply offer different means of achieving the same ends we want and constantly attacking them can at times be counterproductive to our cause.

Sorry. We have to win the fight, not end it. Anything else is a betrayal of our beliefs and would leave the door open for less savoury parties who wouldn't be so shy of negative campaigning. Remember, Labour in the 80s simply refused to go negative - settling for a glorious untainted defeat is a betrayal of the vulnerable people who's lives we seek to improve.

Re: Is party politics making a mockery of democrac (#2)

re number 1
yes true but i don't think that labour members would really if given the choice bring back nationalisation though not on a big scale atleast and tories would not bring back capital punishment, i hope. but it would encourage more people to get involved in politics and show the points of views political party members really feel and hopefully help re-connect people with potics by giving them atleast some deciding power over policy.

number 2
i honestly don't think labour would have somehow failed to get into power inh 197 if it hadn't been for PR. but your missing the point in polit5ics i see no situations where misleading people can possibly help further your cause. if anything it dilutes it with half truths and lies.

number 3
tottally agree
number 4
i agree but what i mean is not attacking people simply for their party but for their beliefs. we should not be attacking politicians from other parties who have similar aims as us and even at times similar methods half as much as we should be attacking peoplewith dangerous idealogical beliefs. attacking people on the left and centre who are not as eurosceptic as others can simply do damage to our own idealogical grounds and put back our cause.